Forgot to respond to this, I use Webstrings on all of my roundwound 34" basses Actually, I use them on everythingI can except flatwound basses (Labella).
One more thing, I had assumed that you did compare the pups soloed also, 'cause if you were always playing them together then I would agree that one being wired backwards could be the problem. Since you didn't really say, let me ask now Did you play them separately?
One problem with online strings is the time to get them. I have used Carvin for inexpensive rounds in the past from time to time. These seem similarly priced and they do have a great selection.
As to soloing pickups see #8 in my review when I talk about single coil hum. Obviously to test single coil hum you have to solo pickups! I don't think they are wired backwards. However the problem easily could be that the inductance/resistance etc. of the coils is such that the response does not peak in the right places and the tone is thin and output weak. So the one wiring thing I DO plan to try soon is to bypass all the pots etc. (eliminates any loading effects of them) and wire the pickups in series (should increase inductance, double output level, and emphasize bass) directly to jack. That should at least show if the pickups at least have any decent tone in there. Especially if I put some other strings one too. That's the plan for the next operation.

