TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Let me clarify that my experience is based on top40 variety wedding/corporate bands. We never play obscure songs. Top40 or nothing at all.Well that may depend on the setting and the audience.
I love it when a band pulls out an obscure tune or two--I might hear a song I don't normally hear--which is cool.
Well said and dbl up on # 10
Its not a party for you
But that's a personal thing. Bottom line is.....they like it. That's all that matters. I keep hearing that argument but if millions of people like something...in what way does it suck??? Would you really want the world to only listen to what YOU think is good music? But this is a whole 'nutha thread topic!I'm on the fence about number 3 too. Audiences know what they like, but that still doesn't mean they know what's good. There are a lot of people out there that like some really popular music that sucks @$$ on any critical level.
It's a digression, but an important one, so I'll keep it short:But that's a personal thing. Bottom line is.....they like it. That's all that matters. I keep hearing that argument but if millions of people like something...in what way does it suck??? Would you really want the world to only listen to what YOU think is good music? But this is a whole 'nutha thread topic!
It's a digression, but an important one, so I'll keep it short:
The top selling ice cream flavor is vanilla because everyone can agree on it. It's statistically safe because its bland. That does mean its good per say, just not flavorful enough to make some one dislike it. That's a pretty lazy way to get to number one. Music is the same way. 99.9% of top selling records aren't ground breaking or challenging, only that .1% sets a new path for everyone else to follow like lemmings. Then there is the stuff that will never be top selling records because they aren't safe or bland, they intentionally accept lower sales to have greater musical or lyrical depth.
That's cool, and I did say it depends on setting/context.Let me clarify that my experience is based on top40 variety wedding/corporate bands. We never play obscure songs. Top40 or nothing at all.
Revised for the ultra sensitive. : )
I put it in a simple list. This took decades to compile. You can argue all you want. But they are the truth. You'll find that out sooner or later.
HAHA! That is exactly what our lead singer says after the first set! Frankly, that particular band is so comfortable on stage that he and I do a bit of a Tom and Dick Smothers thing throughout the show. It never gets long winded, for obvious reasons, but it speaks to one thing not on the list:Anyway great list. I would add to the crowd interaction bit, a joke if I may- "We've received several requests but have decided to continue playing anyway."
Actually, my '55-'65 rock-pop band is very successful with the commentary. It's all part of the SHOW. That being said, we don't do bars, so it may be the venues we play that makes it popular. We do car shows, festivals, jamborees, etc. My "bar" band keeps that sort of stuff to a minimum, usually reserving it for when there is some reason to break, e.g. broken string or guitar switch.I'd say even really famous bands need to learn this one. I came for the music, not the commentary.
My blues trio does almost all obscure tunes - we do some classic covers just to prove we can - but that is our calling card. It seems our audiences like the fact that they get to hear some great music that may sound familiar, but definately not routine. The good thing about obscure tunes is that virtually no one criticizes you for not playing the tune like Stevie Ray!Well that may depend on the setting and the audience.
I love it when a band pulls out an obscure tune or two--I might hear a song I don't normally hear--which is cool.
I might discover a song I like & that is new to me, etc.
A couple of years ago I was at a Blues Festival (As part of the audience)--and there were 8 bands--only two I really knew--and so a lot of the songs were obscure--but I bought some music that day, and have since bought some of the other music.
But this does make sense to consider your audience & context--and if you do play something obscure--don't overdo it.
Also one person's obscure is another's common song--and I have encountered that--songs I thought were common-someone else thought obscure--and vice versa.