• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

The Great Bass Preamp/DI Comparison

Interesting. I never had a chance to check out the original Harmonic Booster and always wanted to check one out. The new version recently hit my Youtube feed (again), so it's now a curiosity (again)... I'm digging it in the video below, and would be interested to hear your further thoughts on this one. Can you expand further on "special sauce?" Also, the manual's description of the Character knob is pretty vague. Can you describe that knob a little further?

It's probably just the settings in the video, but it does kind of seem like it pushes the mids the same way other Darkglass pedals do, which kind of pushed me away from "the Darkglass sound." (I always felt like I was trying to force them into my sound, and never really vibed with them - B3K, B7K, Vintage Ultra, AO Ultra).

Looking forward to hearing any further thoughts, thanks in advance!

5sg.



I have owned both. The original was very noisy which Doug was gracious enough to get his tech here in Ontario to fix....it was a great booster or preamp. I also have the new one. The way I used both I dint find them mid focused some the od's.

I like it. Its not ground breaking, but it does a good job as a boost or as a preamp to add some depth and clarity
 
  • Like
Reactions: fivestringgecko
That Particle Accelerator does look like an interesting curiosity! Will be keeping my eye out for that one as well. I've never had the opportunity to experience an Alembic F-2B though...

5sg.


So, I have the PA, I have the Frog pedals fx1, which also has some additional features. I've owned John K's alembic F2b I think it was called. I've owned the Suncoast f2b and the Sushi is every bit as good at a fraction of the price. Feed it 500ma or more and it's a happy pedal. It's that classic Alembic, Fender 2/10/2 tone stack......I just built a pt nano board around the Sushi pedal to go with my Reiner Saturn V for jV for grab and go jams and small venues...
 
Interesting. I never had a chance to check out the original Harmonic Booster and always wanted to check one out. The new version recently hit my Youtube feed (again), so it's now a curiosity (again)... I'm digging it in the video below, and would be interested to hear your further thoughts on this one. Can you expand further on "special sauce?" Also, the manual's description of the Character knob is pretty vague. Can you describe that knob a little further?

It's probably just the settings in the video, but it does kind of seem like it pushes the mids the same way other Darkglass pedals do, which kind of pushed me away from "the Darkglass sound." (I always felt like I was trying to force them into my sound, and never really vibed with them - B3K, B7K, Vintage Ultra, AO Ultra).

Looking forward to hearing any further thoughts, thanks in advance!

5sg.



The BassTheWorld demo of the Harmonic Booster is probably my favorite representation I've seen and heard of it so far. But I'll do my best to put my opinion into words.

As far as my needs go, I never use distortion. I attempt a clean, glassy sound. Hi-Fi, active, modern single coil type tones, but often play funk covers as well in my band. I prefer an amp that doesn't add much color and I've never sought out the Darkglass signature sound. To my ears, that's basically what the character knob does. There's probably more to it, but turning it clockwise seems to cut low mids and highs, while boosting bass and high mids. But it also seems to give almost a slightly warm compression to those aforementioned boosted frequencies. It's quite pleasant in a mix, but not necessarily amazing by itself. I tend to use the character gently through an amp, but a little bit more aggressively through headphones or IEM's. I like the high end roll off through cans. It's almost like the high end roll off of a blended cab sim and DI signal. Even with the character knob off and light EQ adjustment, it makes a passive bass sound active and an active bass sound even more active(ish). I LOVE it for slap and leads. Instead of the typical mid scoop slap sound that can disappear with light finger style, it stays present in a mix. Basically a "bedroom tone" that can actually sound great with a full band. Hopefully this makes sense.

I'm having LOTS of fun swapping back and forth with the DG and the NUX. DG for the modern, and the NUX with the AGL model for the warmth. Slight dirt for some saturation plays well with the soloed bridge pickup. Adding my own IR in the NUX fed by the DG is such a pleasant combination with both pickups evenly blended for the modern glassy bits.
 
Last edited:
Here's another fun one. Both played with Sadowsky set flat with VTC at 50%.

One clip is Noble, one clip is a mystery device.

Go!

[Invalid or Expired Link Removed]

Clip #1 is Noble with bass boosted to 9:00, treble flat.

Clip #2 is NUX using Aguilar preamp IR.
 
Last edited:
I've been going back and forth with @scubaduba about why his NuX recordings have so much noise. There is a reason. He's keeping the NuX Volume very low. Which means his noise level is pretty much entirely the fixed output circuit noise (from D/A out to the DI Out).

The NuX's DI Out is much hotter than mic level. It's seems like plugging a line-level output into a mic-level input for scuba even though he says he's using a line in. My interface handles the NuX's DI output level with the Volume way up just fine (up to digital clipping at the D/A).

If he could get his NuX volume up, he would get a much better signal-to-noise ratio.

- John
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: TheLopp
Clip #1 is Noble with bass boosted to 9:00, treble flat.

Clip #2 is NUX using Aguilar preamp IR.
giphy.gif

I keep missing the hiss everyone is talking about. Must be my speakers. Just using Labtec computer speakers with a sub that I've had since the dawn of computers. Nothing fancy. But on the plus side, everything sounds fantastic and apparently you don't hear any of the bad parts!
 
Last edited: