• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

The Squier Mini Precision Bass Club

I put short scale GHS Precision flatwounds, 45-95, on mine (set 3020). These strings sound great, no problems at all.

This sounds nice.
I am GASing for a Mini P and curious about the GHS Precision flatwounds.
I currently have a Mustang PJ and a (heavily modded) Bronco both strung with D'Addario flatwound chromes and I like them, especially on the Bronco which is the one I mostly play, the strings are quite broken in since they are a couple of years old and sound really warm.

Anyway, I shall wait after the "virtual" Winter NAMM by end January to see if Fender bring out a maple fretboard Mini P and then I will pull the trigger on this fun little bass.

Oh well, 2021 is the P-bass 70th anniversary and as a Fender fan I feel compelled to own an American made Precision.

Also to consider, Fender might bring out an American made Mustang with just one pickup, maybe in the American Professional series.

That makes for a whole lot of basses.

Now let me think what to say to my wife:roflmao:
 
  • Like
Reactions: DavesnothereCA
I put short scale Chromes on mine. The E wraps around the post for 1/4 tone but it looks solid. I don't expect it to break anytime soon. It does sound bad though, almost out of tune with itself. That might be the short scale though. It looks like I'm the only one with this problem here. The A string has the same issue to a lesser extent.
~
Nah, some of the other folks have not noticed yet, or are excusing it for the other things which they like about the bass, and it IS the [extra] short scale.

IMNSHO, the E needs to be a 105 to 110, and with the proper wrap length of about 30".

A set of 50-65-85-110 would yield better results on basses of this scale.

Those are almost impossible to get, and I expect expensive if you could.

Pyramid custom/bespoke flatwound sets ?
~
 
Last edited:
~
Nah, some of the other folks have not noticed yet, or are excusing it for the other things which they like about the bass, and it IS the [extra] short scale.

IMNSHO, the E needs to be a 105 to 110, and with the proper wrap length of about 30".

A set of 50-65-85-110 would yield better results on basses of this scale.

Those are almost impossible to get, and I expect expensive if you could.

Pyramid custom/bespoke flatwound sets ?
~

Dave, you know I love you like a brother... but, for about the 8 millionth time - thicker gauge strings are a poor choice for short scale basses. You'll get more tension, but lose a lot of musicality. And the shorter the scale, the more that applies. A 110 on a 28.6" scale is going to sound like crap due to its difficulty in flexing properly along such a short scale length.
You repeating over and over that these basses need thicker strings does not make it true. Regular short scale D'Addario Chromes have more than enough tension - in fact they are right on the limit of being too stiff for the scale. Which is why some have mentioned the Chromes almost sound slightly out of tune on the Mini P.
For all we know the GHS Precisions might be the best sounding strings of all on the Mini. And even if they are a bit softer they won't rattle as much as rounds would at the same tension.
 
Last edited:
It is a closing window: a shorter scale length for a low pitch force the player to choose between reduced tension and increased inharmonicity, or to look for a delicate balance between the two.
Ideally, a string built to be inherently more flexible than usual might be the ticket, but the nonstandard length requirement of the Mini-P is an additional complication...
If I had one, I would either order a round-core Newtone set with a 115 or 120 low E or a Pyramid flatwound one with a 110, but I'd also consider modifying the darn thing so that it can accept long-scale strings. I'd be especially curious to try the .118" low B from the 5-string La Bella Low Tension Flexible Flat set (LTF-5A).

If one manages with a standard or thin gauge E that's fantastic. However, I wonder if any of you uses 5-string basses. I would guess most folks don't venture beyond a certain fret on the low B, for reasons of tubby tone (primarily due to the pickup position being closer to the centre of the vibrating string) and inharmonicity (chorusy tone), but if said fret is high enough (say the 9th? 10th?), it means that a usable region between the 3rd and said limit does exist, in which you do indeed already play a 28.6" scale with a 120 to 135 string (which would convert to: open to 6th or 7th fret on the Mini).
To the opposite end of the spectrum, I guess there are players who in fact do not use the B string past the 4th or 5th fret, or just occasionally, or who plain don't own a fiver precisely because they dislike the tone of the fifth string, among other reasons. To those, my argument is invalid. Plus, the same diameter on a 28.6" scale, compared to 3rd fret of a 34", means less total string stretching upon the attack, and a somewhat firmer feel, which probably contributes to standard/light gauges working at all on a short-shorty.
 
Dave, you know I love you like a brother... but, for about the 8 millionth time - thicker gauge strings are a poor choice for short scale basses. You'll get more tension, but lose a lot of musicality. And the shorter the scale, the more that applies. A 110 on a 28.6" scale is going to sound like crap due to its difficulty in flexing properly along such a short scale length.
You repeating over and over that these basses need thicker strings does not make it true. Regular short scale D'Addario Chromes have more than enough tension - in fact they are right on the limit of being too stiff for the scale. Which is why some have mentioned the Chromes almost sound slightly out of tune on the Mini P.
For all we know the GHS Precisions might be the best sounding strings of all on the Mini. And even if they are a bit softer they won't rattle as much as rounds would at the same tension.
I still have the original 40-95 rounds on my 30" Bronco and the low E sounds nice and deep. I too now think that a thick string would just produce very little sound on a short scale. There's a reason why Leo Fender chose 34", the difference in resonance, unplugged, is staggering.
 
~
Nah, some of the other folks have not noticed yet, or are excusing it for the other things which they like about the bass, and it IS the [extra] short scale.

IMNSHO, the E needs to be a 105 to 110, and with the proper wrap length of about 30".

A set of 50-65-85-110 would yield better results on basses of this scale.

Those are almost impossible to get, and I expect expensive if you could.

Pyramid custom/bespoke flatwound sets ?
~

i find thicker strings uncumfortable to play, and i don't mind lower tension, more flexible strings - my mini P is strung with 40-95 rounds, and i like it that way.
 
I haven't been following this thread for a while and didn't want to read through it all.
I would like to know if anybody has put flatwound strings on the Mini P and can confirm the E string did not break, possibly telling brand of strings and gauges.
Thanks!

Before Brexit - I paid €52 (euro) (about US $60.49) for Pyramid Chrome-Nickel Flatwound Strings for Fender Mini-Bass
thick wound length 77,5 cm / total length 105 cm .045 .065 .085 .105

The price included delivery from Germany to sunny England UK.

The price may have gone up 5% at the start of Oct.
 
Before Brexit - I paid €52 (euro) (about US $60.49) for Pyramid Chrome-Nickel Flatwound Strings for Fender Mini-Bass
thick wound length 77,5 cm / total length 105 cm .045 .065 .085 .105

The price included delivery from Germany to sunny England UK.

The price may have gone up 5% at the start of Oct.
Will you favor us with a photo of your headstock showing how the windings look? Asking for a friend...;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: DavesnothereCA
HB Shorty - Hofner SS Rounds - .040-.095 (Ricky killer)
Squier Badtz Maru Bronco - GHS SS Precision Flats - .045-.095 (olde skoole thump)
Squier Mini P - Ibanez Mikro Rounds - .045-.105 (such variety! wow!)

These strings were all designed and engineered for short scale basses. None have "floppy" or "weak" E strings. IME.

Strings designed and engineered for "regular" scale basses, that are then cut to size for short scale, can exhibit "floppiness" because physics.
 
Will you favor us with a photo of your headstock showing how the windings look? Asking for a friend...;)

I don’t have the flatwounds on my mini at the moment - but here’s a photo I posted earlier of Pyramid bespoke / custom length tapewound strings - which were the same price as the flatwounds I quoted before.

7A5F271E-9F6A-4300-BE82-F392FE49D4D5.jpeg
 
Last edited:
I don’t have the flatwounds on my mini at the moment - but here’s a photo I posted earlier of Pyramid bespoke / custom length tapewound strings - which were the same price as the flatwounds I quoted before.

View attachment 4118567
~
It escapes me whether or not you told us before, but what are the gauges of the tapewounds in the pic ?

And is that coffee or tea in the mug ? :)
~
 
  • Like
Reactions: RodRy