• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

The Sushi Box FX Secret Society

What is the difference in sound between SMD and HW?
At home, through headphones, there’s a definite difference. The HW sounds a little bigger and fuller.

In a live mix, through the PA with drums, guitars, keys, and vocals, the difference isn’t really noticeable. Even in my IEMS, playing live, there isn’t really much of a difference between the two.

I know this goes against the general consensus that HW is so much better, but I’d say it depends on your use—at home or maybe for recording, I’d agree it’s maybe worth the extra money. But for live use, the difference is probably there, but for me, not noticeable enough to spend the extra over SMD. And the only thing that *I* personally care about is live use. So moving forward, I’ll happily stick with SMD versions if still available.
 
At home, through headphones, there’s a definite difference. The HW sounds a little bigger and fuller.

In a live mix, through the PA with drums, guitars, keys, and vocals, the difference isn’t really noticeable. Even in my IEMS, playing live, there isn’t really much of a difference between the two.

I know this goes against the general consensus that HW is so much better, but I’d say it depends on your use—at home or maybe for recording, I’d agree it’s maybe worth the extra money. But for live use, the difference is probably there, but for me, not noticeable enough to spend the extra over SMD. And the only thing that *I* personally care about is live use. So moving forward, I’ll happily stick with SMD versions if still available.
Thanks for the feedback, I appreciate honest reviews. I still have SMD pedals on my board that I'm not in a hurry to replace. People like the HW versions so I'll continue to make them as long as there is demand, but the SMD versions are a lot less work for me both in design and assembly.
 
Thought I’d post this little pedal board I put together for ampless gigs. Might be the wrong place. Wanted to show off my Underground Accelerator.
8A9AFA98-44B7-42C6-8463-7B3AD65B28C5.jpeg
 
Thought I’d post this little pedal board I put together for ampless gigs. Might be the wrong place. Wanted to show off my Underground Accelerator.View attachment 4762424
Looks like a solid setup! I'm not officially affiliated with Lightning Boy, but I love his products and I've found that my stuff works great with his stuff. Can't say enough good about Lightning Boy.
 
When the volume on More is all the way up, is it at unity or does it act as a boost? If it acts as a boost, about how much db gain is there?
It's definitely a boost, unity gain is around 10 o'clock if I remember right. Let me see if I can do some math for actual gain level.
 
I'll have to ask: What exactly is consuming a tube? I think I read somewhere that it's the actual 'work' and not by idling in warmed up state ?
I once read that over the long-term life of a tube, the coating on the cathode slowly strips away, reducing the amount of electrons produced and weakening the overall amplification ability of the tube... that coating very slowly depletes whenever voltage is applied to the cathode, regardless of if it's actually receiving any input or not.
No idea if it's true! It's just one of the things that I've heard is supposedly responsible for tubes not being able to run forever.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sushi Box FX