TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
I think you are hearing why the B15 is such a popular recording amp and the SB gives the same pleasure.So this is a fun one, I got my Carvin AC40 to sound like an upright going through my PJB BG-400. Very cool, might just use this to go direct at rehearsals now (assuming there's a PA available). Is there a HPF built into this? I noticed that it cut some of the mud out of the signal from the Realist Copperhead on my upright - I tried it both with and without my FDeck HPF, and while it (obviously) didn't completely cut out the mud it definitely made a difference. Just curious.
I'm really glad I decided to give Dreamcatcher the 350V treatment ....... I think I can say it just might be my favorite thing I make. Like if there was a Señor Sushi signature preamp, I think this would be it.
View attachment 5276396
What is flat-ish on Elementary?
Is it a 0-10-0 style eq or is it cut/boost on all BMT?
As a general comment, not a criticism on these transformers, there are a couple of puzzling conclusions being made that make no technical or scientific sense.I can probably explain that with very few words but with pretty graphs. Unagi transformer has a flatter response at lower frequencies.
Unagi Transformer frequency response:
View attachment 5274586
LBA Transformer frequency response:
View attachment 5274588
View attachment 5276577 View attachment 5276578
It's definitely my fave S-Box as well. I kind of wish I needed another, but after recently rigging up "my favourite everything and still small enough to sit on top of a cab" board on a 9.5x11.5 split level NUX Bumble Bee I'm feeling strangely ´board stable’.......
Generally this involves a low source impedance and a high load impedance than the design goals. An unloaded or very lightly loaded audio transformer can appear to "defy gravity".To go along with what @agedhorse is saying, I have some $0.99 transformers from eBay that test flat from 20 to 20k in the right circuit.
All fair points. I'll freely admit my brain sometimes tries to make my ears hear things that it thinks should be there. When I see these graphs then listen to the two side-by-side, it's not an "AHA! It's so obvious!", it's more of a "Hmm, I think I hear something there." It's a subtle difference, but I feel like I hear something and now my brain is trying to say "this must be it".As a general comment, not a criticism on these transformers, there are a couple of puzzling conclusions being made that make no technical or scientific sense.
Looking at the plots, at 20Hz there is ~1dB of difference, and at 30Hz there is ~1/2dB of difference. This alone is well within the normal manufacturing tolerances of 5% components, even without considering the variability of a tube.
Also, considering that a (ridiculously low) 20Hz HPF will be -3dB at 20Hz, how much if the potential difference is purely academic?
Another critical issue when characterizing frequency response on an audio transformer is the source and load impedance. Change either and the frequency response can change a lot. There are ways to use this characteristic to artificially create the perception of differences that are due purely to the interaction with source and load.
Another characteristic of audio transformers that’s often overlooked is what the distortion is at various frequencies and as the source and load impedances change. This can be extremely enlightening when investigating perceptions of difference between transformers.
All well explained, Andy, as always.This is exactly why players focusing on amp distortion of less than 0.1% as "better" are missing the entire picture of why an MI amp is in part an instrument used to create additional tones from the instrument itself.
Much of this can also be achieved in a suitable preamp that uses the same principles, but plugging straight in makes it more difficult unless the sound tech grasps what you are trying to do and has the tools needed to achieve this (either through suitable channel strip processing and/or plug-in processing).All well explained, Andy, as always.
Your sentence that I quoted from your post is particularly noteworthy for all those people out there who would have us bass players get rid of all amplifiers, completely. I don't know how many times I've fought with sound techs about using an amp, either onstage or in recording. They don't get that amps are our sound, and contribute to the tones we need to hear to play at our best. Amps are a big part of our identity as musicians.
I just find it ugly personally to each their ownYa mean them bees don't have any knees???. IMHO, it doesn't matter...it's the sound that counts.