• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

The Vinyl Comeback Is Stalling?

I have a pile of old LPs, some of which never made it to CD (for example: The Roots of Rock'Roll on the Savoy label). I bought a preamp for my Sony turntable, which had been gathering dust--literally--in a closet. Plugged it into my desktop machine, and so far I've converted about half of them to FLAC. They sound just like the record.:D

PS: I learned about FLAC at something called The King Cake Crypt Redux. If you're into out-of-print jazz, you'll love it.
 
Sad to see music sales go down, but on the flipside: Good.

In a day and age where digital storage is so inexpensive and networks are so fast and reliable, physical media is about as relevant as using a sextant to navigate, or driving a Hummer in a crowded city. We don't need to generate more clutter and/or landfill material.

However, I do wish that the Spotify-type business model would go away for something more along the lines of Bandcamp (you stream x number of times before you have to buy the track or album).

i wish digital streaming media sounded as good as cd/LP. For, it just doesnt.
 
The reason I sorta went back to vinyl is.......
1. I still have my over-large collection ( yep, I squirrel'd them away)
2. I only buy from a local used record store, where I haunt the "scratch and pop" sections. Most of them sound better than my old ones.
3. Much of what I buy is tough to find any other way.
4. Nostalgia...... Perusing albums, and looking at covers, is something I've loved to do since " Meet the Beatles".
 
I'm completely happy with the convience of streaming, despite the compression, and have long since moved on from any physical format. The thing I'm saddest about is the abandonment of creative album art. I support artists by buying tickets and merch (whoever said bands have crummy merch is right), which was always how rock bands got paid. I'm more interested in up and coming stuff than the average TBer, and most of these people have cheap tickets or are at festivals. If I only listened to old Miles records or whatever, I would maybe feel different.
 
I just got two CD's a day ago.
Vinyl is for wall displays only.
As I am NOT going to be buying a record player!

Edit:I like CD's over downloaded music because I get all the band info and pics in the printed liner.
Downloads get nothing but music.

Not always. Certain labels digitize all of the booklet information as well as the actual music.

And with the increased shipping rates and the horrific Canadian dollar, it would cost me at least $30, for most CDs. And with the amount of new music I buy, that is not happening.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Watchootognbout
I've been buying vinyl since the '80s, and over the decades have incrementally assembled a system upon which their playback gives me great joy.

I hope that those of you who don't like vinyl never find yourselves so captivated by such pleasures; it's an expensive thing to jump into all at once. :woot:
 
  • Like
Reactions: knumbskull
Inflation and limited manufacturing stalled growth last year. Everyone I know is on a 8 month to a year wait list to get pressed as the music world resumes itself. There are kids - actual teenagers - buying records in stacks in shops I go to. Its niche market, but its a consistent niche. It was never going to be the way everyone consumed music again. Digital is too convenient.
Records are an active listening experience, a ritual, and has its own little cultural pockets. That appeals to a lot of people.

Well, you don't know me, but we're on a 5-6 month wait for our vinyl.
 
  • Like
Reactions: smokescreens
Not always. Certain labels digitize all of the booklet information as well as the actual music.

And with the increased shipping rates and the horrific Canadian dollar, it would cost me at least $30, for most CDs. And with the amount of new music I buy, that is not happening.
Certain labels........
 
And - newer 'remasters' are not ALWAYS better than the prior 'analog to digital' masters either. I have several examples of albums where I own the 1st or 2nd gen CD versions of albums I also own on vinyl, AND the 'newly remastered!' versions from the past decade or so that came out. The 'newly remastered' versions are unlistenable. Overly compressed, tinny sounding, too in your face. The first-gen transfers sound much closer to vinyl in terms of EQ/compression and wider dynamic range. 'Remastered' isn't always superior to the original if the remastering engineer loses sight of what the album truly sounded like to begin with.
I couldn't agree more -- and it's why I generally avoid remastered versions except under unusual circumstances, like the (edit: aforementioned, I shoulda read the whole thread) Brendan O'Brien remix of Ten, for example.

Loudness war - Wikipedia
 
  • Like
Reactions: JazznFunk
In the 1920’s, cigars were the most popular form of tobacco consumption and in the 90’s there was a “cigar boom” (I know because I got caught up in it). In the 60’s and 70’s vinyl was the most popular form of music on demand consumption and 50 years later experienced a resurgence (got caught and still in that one, too). Maybe, just maybe, kids today will put down their cellphones and game consoles and pick up guitars, basses, and drums…form bands, and do all the things we did fifty years ago.

And get off my lawn.
 
  • Like
Reactions: EddiePlaysBass
I’m writing this as my 9 year old is in the other room listening to a Laney Jones album on his new mid-level turntable he asked for and received at Christmas. Sounds really good to him and me. This is an extremely pleasant experience for me, contrasted with what he was doing previously: “alexa play (whatever random song he’s into).”

The vinyl album comeback has never been about audio quality, it’s about connection and experience. Taking away the listener’s ability to easily skip tracks and forcing them to appreciate the album as a whole, artwork included. Bringing back the album as a cohesive work of art, limiting filler and holding attention. As an artist I prefer to create and sell a product that I know the listener will experience in the manner it was intended (well more likely than via streaming).

My son is learning to give songs a chance, to take care of his records and equipment, and treat music listening as a sort of ceremony that gives it mire heft and meaning than the ubiquitous streaming over headphones experience most of us music lovers lament. I think vinyl should be mandatory for all music listeners so that they can properly appreciate what technology has done for convenience and fidelity.
EXACTLY

:woot: :woot: :woot: :woot: :woot: :woot: :woot:
 
I didn't know the later edition of "Ten" was a proper remix! I thought it was "just another remaster" and totally ignored it. I'll definitely check it out! Thanks!

There was a 2-disc version in a digipack that had the *remastered original mix (which still sounds good), and then the totally redone mix AND remaster. The remix opens things up in such a great way that the band really wanted to do in the first place.... much clearer, more nuance to guitar solos, Eddie's vocals.... and does away with the washy reverb that dominated the original record.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 31HZ
I do love vinyl, and occasionally buy a new copy of something, usually some classic, like a really nice pressing. But it's just so expensive, I reserve it for those special things. Otherwise I'm very happy listening to my decades-old records, many of which are pretty thrashed (but I dig that vibe). My 17 year old however, spends a lot more than I do on new vinyl--at around $25 a pop on average.
I wish it were cheaper to press vinyl in small batches. I'd love to make say, ten 12"s of some of my own stuff just to give to people, and to have for myself. But I can never really justify the $.
 
I have a newish turntable and I enjoy playing classic records in something like the way they were originally heard.

But they do have significant drawbacks, I get what must be an abnormal number that skip right from the jump, and the prices have been increasing steadily with the runaway inflation the rest of the world has seen in the last two years.
 
I buy vinyl from bands for the same reason that I used to buy CDs - to help support local and touring acts. I don’t play any of the vinyl that I own because I don’t care to make the investment in an analog home stereo system. And I haven’t had a device that can play a cd for at least 10 years now, so I’d rather get the big format for the artwork than the small format which is basically just a waste of plastic to me.

I almost never buy music from anyone who is not independent. Major artists all get streamed in my household.

I’d much rather buy a record than a band tshirt. PSA: Your tshirt designs are terrible, everyone. Seriously.

:)
When I was in SanDiego a decade ago I went to the Casbah to catch a couple of interesting bands and I ended up buying the T-shirt because the guitarist told me they actually make quite a bit more profit on the shirts than the CDs. The Chicano Batman shirt design was actually really good back then, I like it much better than their [This invalid link has been removed]...