• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

The way bass "should" sound

I have no one favorite sound that's "what bass should sound like." I like being able to get a variety of sounds from new roundwound twang to thumpy dead hollowbody thunk. And that's why I have a few basses and not just one. The only sounds I don't care for are bridge pickup-forward sounds like Jaco used to get and very bright tweetery sounds like Marcus Miller. Great players who revolutionized bass and I love listening to their stuff sometimes, but I hate those sounds.
 
His tone is not bad.
He plays it strange though.
Which is fine, just a conversational observation.
Seems like he's letting a delay do all the work.
It sounds really mechanical.

Roger didn't play it like that.
Yes he did. He even hits a note at the beginning of it where you can clearly hear the delay.
 
This one gave me something to think about as it sat up front in the mix and was so well balanced tone wise and clean.


This guy showed me how to get gritty.


These brothers put together a "Modern sound" that was a revelation at the time. Particularly tracks 5,6,9 what tone ...Thank you Mr Haslip


And of course my two Rocks were Geddy and Chuck. Two completely different tonal palettes that opened my eyes.
 
Fair enough, what I'm hearing I guess is the fact that it was originally double-tracked, hard panned, and one bass has the tone all the way down.
Never knew that before you told me, but I've never listened to it with headphones, either. Just listened to it, and it's definitely two tracks. But the bassy bass track sounds to me like he's just hitting the one until he plays an A, then he holds it out till he goes back to B. Then the echo track carries the off beats.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SunnBass
6:26 You know what's comin' lol!! And I'm not even normally a big fan of picked bass or playing close to the bridge. Roger Waters is the exception for me. I've always loved his tone and his lines. Simple, effective and instantly recognisable.

P-bass + Hiwatt has always been a particular favourite of mine. Luckily I've got about 15 of the former + a really nice specimen of the latter. But my DR201 only sounds THAT great when played WAY to loud for any practical purpose. I'm only hanging on to it for my tour of Roman amphitheaters. :D I should probably get a DR103 instead...

 
Obviously there is no single answer to this, but I thought it would be fun to get people to post clips with their favorite bass tones. I'll start. The first 1:20 of this is pretty close to the "sound in my head."


Comparing that one vs. this one is a great graphical illustration of the drastic difference between P with flats vs. J with roundwounds on two roughly similar pieces: