• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

The Who fire Zac Starkey

As good as Zep was on record, they were usually not very good live - too drunk to play well was a common issue. The Who was the band that, if you asked other bands from their era, nobody wanted to follow - they were THE real deal live.

I don't know, I heard that some rando guy who worked in a machine shop said they weren't all that... :rolleyes:
I was fortunate enough to attend one night of their run of concerts at Madison Square Garden in NYC, the same shows filmed and recorded for "The Song Remains The Same" — and they put on a terrific show, playing well for hours with no apparent issues of either fatigue or substance impairment. Therefore, I dispute the assertion that "they were usually not very good live." Granted, Bonham and Page had some significant substance abuse problems toward the end of their concert days, but the only concerts of theirs that I ever heard were actually bad occurred after Bonham's death, when they tried to regroup with substitute drummers. Happily for everyone, that all changed with the final reunion concert that featured Jason Bonham on the drum stool.

Over the past few decades, I have heard far more credible reports about other bands having problems with one or more members being either chemically impaired or unprofessional in a petty, childish, entitled way (e.g., feuding with other band members, etc.)
  • There was a now-infamous Eagles concert where Glenn Frey and Don Felder were so furious with one another that they spent much of the show threatening to beat each other up.
  • Keith Moon famously was so inebriated at one concert by The Who that he could not play and the band had to ask if there was a drummer in the audience who could come up and fill in.
  • From personal experience, I recall seeing Moby Grape at the Fillmore East with Skip Spence onstage playing very energetically, but completely inaudible. From what we in the audience could see, whatever he was playing on his guitar did not seem to match the music being played by the rest of the band, and my friends and I could only presume that his amp was either turned way down or on standby, or possibly turned off entirely.
 
138ddeb8-4e25-4b45-9814-3f6dfa7b1d98.e5e6979346f41149f889370b8c3838c2.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: dmt
This was posted on Facebook on 4/19:
1745440734762.png

News Flash! Who Backs Zak!
He's not being asked to step down from The Who.
There have been some communication issues, personal and private on all sides, that needed to be dealt with, and these have been aired happily.
Roger and I would like Zak to tighten up his latest evolved drumming style to accommodate our non-orchestral line up and he has readily agreed. I take responsibility for some of the confusion. Our TCT shows at the Royal Albert Hall were a little tricky for me. I thought that four and a half weeks would be enough time to recover completely from having a complete knee replacement. (Why did I ever think I could land on my knees?) Wrong!
Maybe we didn’t put enough time into sound checks, giving us problems on stage. The sound in the centre of the stage is always the most difficult to work with. Roger did nothing wrong but fiddle with his in-ear monitors. Zak made a few mistakes and he has apologised. Albeit with a rubber duck drummer.
We are a family, this blew up very quickly and got too much oxygen. It’s over. We move forward now with optimism and fire in our bellies.
As for Roger, fans can enjoy his forthcoming solo shows with his fabulous drummer, Scott Devours, who it was rumoured might replace Zak in The Who and has always been supportive of the band.
I owe Scott an apology for not crushing that rumour before it spread. He has been hurt by this. I promise to buy him a very long drink and give him a hug.
Pete Townshend
19 April 2025
 
This was posted on Facebook on 4/19:
View attachment 7209688
News Flash! Who Backs Zak!
He's not being asked to step down from The Who.
There have been some communication issues, personal and private on all sides, that needed to be dealt with, and these have been aired happily.
Roger and I would like Zak to tighten up his latest evolved drumming style to accommodate our non-orchestral line up and he has readily agreed. I take responsibility for some of the confusion. Our TCT shows at the Royal Albert Hall were a little tricky for me. I thought that four and a half weeks would be enough time to recover completely from having a complete knee replacement. (Why did I ever think I could land on my knees?) Wrong!
Maybe we didn’t put enough time into sound checks, giving us problems on stage. The sound in the centre of the stage is always the most difficult to work with. Roger did nothing wrong but fiddle with his in-ear monitors. Zak made a few mistakes and he has apologised. Albeit with a rubber duck drummer.
We are a family, this blew up very quickly and got too much oxygen. It’s over. We move forward now with optimism and fire in our bellies.
As for Roger, fans can enjoy his forthcoming solo shows with his fabulous drummer, Scott Devours, who it was rumoured might replace Zak in The Who and has always been supportive of the band.
I owe Scott an apology for not crushing that rumour before it spread. He has been hurt by this. I promise to buy him a very long drink and give him a hug.
Pete Townshend
19 April 2025
Is he hugging him, or restraining him?
 
I just watched the Royal Albert Hall / Song is Over - there's got to be more to it than just that mess.

Drums too loud on that stage? Try turning them down in the monitors and / or mains.
Maybe they should have fired the monitor guy?

I was cringing already before Roger messed up - apparently he forgot the song and comes in early over an iconic bass fill - and Zach recovers nicely.

I couldn't sit through that - just too painful - (as was the Superbowl performance)

There was a time they were one of my favorite bands, but they haven't aged well for me.
Glad I saw them before John passed.

There comes a time.....
I bet he wish he'd died before he got old.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Dlew919
Apparently Zak is no longer fired.

No, no, no. It was all a misunderstanding. Pete read a rumor on The App Formerly Known as Twitter that Zak had been fired, so he sent him a condolence, which Zak took as his notice. It eventually got all sorted out and the band went to a pub for a few dozen beers, after which they trashed the place in memory of Moonie.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Dlew919
And, that's a wrap. Again. No word here if Zac will play on this tour. But I suspect this kerfluffle contributed to this. I bet Rog and Pete are not going to hang it up for sure, but maybe not as The Who, which makes sense to me.
 
According to this source, Starkey has been fired again.