i'm not the poster with the fodera nor have i ever owned or played one, but some nicer basses i owned briefly didn't live up to my imagination for a variety of reasons, none of them quality.
i once ordered a custom acoustic guitar from a builder, and while almost everything was what i asked for on paper, there were a number of disappointments. ironically the wife of the husband-and-wife owned music store that agreed to sell it on commission for me ended up loving it so much she bought it for herself, and she was used to dealing with the best. so it wasn't actually a bad guitar - it just wasn't right for me from the sound to the looks to the feel.