• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Thunderbird Club

I had the same experience. Not sure when it happened or even IF it happened but it SEEMS to me like many bands these days are EQing the bass a bit further back in the mix and boosting the vocals quite a bit forward. Again, I might just be imagining things, but I did have my hearing checked and it’s fine.

I think the industry dictates that and other than a few incidences over decades have always mostly buried the bass in the mix. Those incidences have be '60s Motown/Wrecking Crew/Muscle Shoals, generally '70s Funk & Disco, '80s New Wave where the bass was out front, and some bands/songs since then. (Pixies, Primus, RHCP's and other more recent examples) It always happens when I have recorded with my bands over the years - I have to ask for more pronounced bass from the board when doing post-recording balancing/mixing as it's buried by everything else.

The other reason is how music is delivered now - all very compressed to sound "good" over phones. (not headphones!)

Legendary producer Jerry Wexler replied without hesitation when asked what he wanted inscribed into his headstone - "More Bass"

upload_2024-5-13_11-26-11.jpeg

Jerry Wexler - Wikipedia
 
Last edited:
IMO it's a cool effect for the bass to drop out for a while. It's satisfying for the listener when it returns.

I agree - I'm continually working to make my bass-lines with BG & TSC as sparse as possible (including dropping out) for the dynamics you describe. Especially over the length of a song - I start by sparsely establishing the root notes and add seasoning over the verses/choruses. A slow/deliberate build-up always charges the song for a big ending/release.
 
I think the industry dictates that and other than a few incidences over decades have always mostly buried the bass in the mix. Those incidences have be '60s Motown/Wrecking Crew/Muscle Shoals, generally '70s Funk & Disco, '80s New Wave where the bass was out front, and some bands/songs since then. (Pixies, Primus, RHCP's and other more recent examples) It always happens when I have recorded with my bands over the years - I have to ask for more pronounced bass from the board when doing post-recording balancing/mixing as it's buried by everything else.

The other reason is how music is delivered now - all very compressed to sound "good" over phones. (not headphones!)

Legendary producer Jerry Wexler replied without hesitation when asked what he wanted inscribed into his headstone - "More Bass"

View attachment 5447182
Jerry Wexler - Wikipedia
Geo - always enjoy reading your observations. Insightful and informative. Hadn’t really made the connection with the prevalence of micro speakers in phones, laptops and iPads (primary listening devices these days) and how that’s driving how sound is mixed.

Compare that with the monster Cerwin Vega and Pioneer speakers and subwoofers that we listened through in the 70’s through the 90’s home stereo systems as our primary music listening devices.
 
Geo - always enjoy reading your observations. Insightful and informative. Hadn’t really made the connection with the prevalence of micro speakers in phones, laptops and iPads (primary listening devices these days) and how that’s driving how sound is mixed.

Compare that with the monster Cerwin Vega and Pioneer speakers and subwoofers that we listened through in the 70’s through the 90’s home stereo systems as our primary music listening devices.

Yah, the other perplexing exception was the advent of boom-boxes and those sub-woofers in cars -
 
Geo - always enjoy reading your observations. Insightful and informative. Hadn’t really made the connection with the prevalence of micro speakers in phones, laptops and iPads (primary listening devices these days) and how that’s driving how sound is mixed.

Compare that with the monster Cerwin Vega and Pioneer speakers and subwoofers that we listened through in the 70’s through the 90’s home stereo systems as our primary music listening devices.
One thing I've had to turn to in my mixing gigs is parallel saturation to make the bass more perceptibly audible on smaller speakers
 
We've gone full circle, bass used to be mixed for transistor radios; hence Pbasses, now compressed for smartphones. Doesn't explain the heavy kicks. I guess those are for oversized subs in cars (and side by sides)

The over-emphasized kick is a club thing - sooo loud, it drowns the bass out! Don't know the rationality behind it.
 

Latest posts