For those of you contemplating going down the EMG Geezer Butler P/J path on a bird or other nearly as fine a bass here’s a before and after sound clip on my mid 1990’s Epiphone Non Reverse originally equipped with an Eppi PJ set and now equipped with a passive EMG Geezer Butler PJ set…
View attachment 7259377
Stock pickups…
View attachment 7259381
Geezer pickups…
View attachment 7259382
Both recordings were set with all knobs maxed. Finger playing on the G and D strings, right hand over split P, fresh nickel round wounds.
My thoughts…
Sound - the Geezers are noticeably brighter on the top end, cleaner and tighter on the bottom end. They have more punch than the Eppi pups. With the tone knob slightly backed off and the neck pickup slightly favored the two pickups sound relatively similar. A strong lower mid punch is very easy to EQ in on the Geezers, not as easy on the more creamy Eppi pups. Both sound very good to my ears (although the Geezer recording picked up a lot of poor technique string noise, my bad not the pups) but I suspect the EMGs would be a better fit in a live stage setting. I also suspect that pick action would really set these things on fire.
Quality - top notch, solderless connections and dead easy instructions.
Fit - so so on the Eppi NR. The split P screw tabs were quite a bit smaller than the stock Eppi tabs so there’s a bit of air gap in the pick guard. The Jazz pickup was a perfect fit though. Exposed coils look nice on this bass but don’t line up exactly with the strings, doesn’t seem to effect the quality of the sound though. If you have string/coil OCD you might want to think twice about these or possibly get a bridge that provides adjustable string spacing.
Cost - at about $200 they aren’t an expensive upgrade. The set comes with both the P and Jazz pickups, both volume pots and the tone pot, an output jack, all the necessary wiring harnesses and all screws/washers/nuts to install everything. The only thing it does not include (and in my opinion should be provided) are knobs, but there’s so many knob options on in the market out there I guess it would be difficult to find something that pleases everybody.
So there ya go, get a set if you’re so inclined.