I see you there, I'm inclined to see how the wood is under the finish. For the price, if there's actually no wood damage, I'll probably do it. I'm pretty adaptable to things like finishes and compromise, and I know a guy who might be able to make it invisible to the touch. If not there's always wet sandpaper and steel wool.
I appreciate the no-compromise angle though concerning what you're going to spend a lot of quality time with. It does occur to me that maybe it's time to get a new standard... Raise my game up a notch, level up, expect more, walk a cleaner path...
NAH!! I'll be back!