I seriously doubt you being a lower sphincter, but do agree with everything you said. Normally they get the cat from Cow Town Guitars and he seems to know his stuff.
All "experts" and techs are not created equal. I bought my '64 Pbass through a friend selling it for Teddy Gentry (Alabama). His friend not mine. When I got the bass and took it apart it had 67 PUs and pots in it. I told him about it and he said that he had had the guitar inspected by a very reputable tech in Nashville and I found that hard to believe. I sent him pics and said, well he might've looked at everything but he didn't look at the pot codes or the back of the PU. I told him, as you can imagine, the electronics are as important as about anything else as far as Valley goes. He finally sent some money back to offset it not having original pick ups. Also asked if he would mind getting something signed by Teddy Gentry proving that it was he was his. (Knew it was because I knew they were friends and worked together on documented projects.) Got the money never got the note from Teddy he said he would be glad to get.
I didn't buy the base because Heady owned it, I just wanted one that here and seem like a decent price and I like the color--mainly because it was in a Sunburst. I didn't care for the pick ups at all in it and eventually sewed the pick ups in the wiring harness which more than paid for the new Klein vintage pick ups that do sound fantastic and correct year pots. It's got some Pyramid Gold flats and sounds absolutely fantastic. The 67's were thin sounding and nasally. It went from the worst sounding bass I owned to definitely one in top-tier.
It's actually a crossover year. The neck is a late '63 and the body early '64.
View attachment 4455719