Favourite from your live run through?
Excellent and tough question. I ranked each bass from most to least favorite in each heat (allowing for ties if necessary).
According to the total ranking of scores across all three heats my most favorite to least favorite would be:
1) Greco with scores of 1, 1 and 2 for a total of 4 - clearly at the top of every category
2) Goth with scores of 3, 1 and 1 for a total of 5 - darn close to the Greco (the Cobalt flats and cap job really make this bird shine)
3) BlingBird with scores of 2, 3 and 1 for a total of 6 - not shabby at all, a solid performer
4) 2015 with scores of 1, 5 and 1 for a total of 7 - this speaks more to the pros/cons of tape wound strings
5) 2013 with scores of 3, 2 and 3 for a total of 8 - unbalanced output on the A string did this bass in
6) VP with scores of 4, 4 and 1 for a total of 9 - shocked, never noticed any shortcomings until this shootout
The Greco on top doesn’t surprise me at all, it’s just a great sounding bass in every setting. However, the VP on the bottom sure surprised me, it’s a fantastic sounding bass, until you play it back to back with some of the others which just seem to have a bit of something extra (more content, expression or character) in their sound. That said, I’d still take my VP over just about every Jazz or P bass I’ve played.
The 2015 faired better than I thought it would, it tied for first place in two of the three heats, but failed miserably at the vibrato heat. Blame both the wins and losses on the tape wound strings. With different strings I suspect this bass would still place a hair below the Greco/Goth/BlingBird, roughly in the middle of the pack. The 2013 Tbird was also an eye opener, the third heat highlighted a major flaw that I wasn’t aware of, there is a noticeable volume drop between the E and A string. Might be a bad string, might be a set up issue, might be some odd phase cancellation or might just be the nature of the bass. I’ll be looking closer at that one.