—I ordered a new Squier VM Jazz bass years ago, and it had some imperfections. I contacted the seller and negotiated a discount. You should do the same.
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
To return or not to return…
- Thread starter Captain Chaos
- Start date
If it plays and sounds good I'd keep it. But, I'd also point out the imperfections and to GC and ask for a discount.
Frame the question though as if you are going to return it. They will not want it back as it will have to be sold as used or 'B' stock.
Frame the question though as if you are going to return it. They will not want it back as it will have to be sold as used or 'B' stock.
Looks like all the imperfections are on the back, out of sight. If the bass is a good as you say I'd keep it. If it bugs you enough to put up a thread about it, maybe you should return it! The suggestions about a discount are worth following up. Would that be enough to help you ignore the blemishes?
If it impedes your ability to play and fully enjoy the instrument (even just knowing it's there every time you pick it up), return it. If you're the type who regularly dings the body up by putting the bass in its case, keep it and consider this a free "relic starter kit". Everybody's tolerance level is different and what is fine for one may be heinous to another. Hope this helps.
Get a discount or return it. That's unacceptable for a bass that wasn't sold as B stock.
As has been said, if you love the sound, it plays great and you can live with the imperfections, then I'd just keep it and contact them with well documented photos of the issues and ask for a discount.
It annoys me that it probably got manhandled along the way. They don’t ship them with gig bags so it must had gotten damaged from shipping and the tummy rest doesn’t bother me much.
It’s GC. They say they won’t do that. Just returns…
I’m gonna call the manager and see what he can do.
Pretty much this. If that bass just has "it" when you play it.... if it just feels and sounds ridiculously good.... I would keep it and enjoy the "imperfections" as a couple of things that make that bass unlike any other.
In short, this isn't a rational decision. It's an emotional one. If there are too many positive emotions to ignore, keep it. If you can't get around those two blemishes, and you think about them more than anything else when you pick it up, return it and hope the next one plays and feels just as good.
The orange peeling on the waist is an imperfection. In the other picture, there is so much reflection that I can’t tell what you are referring to. In any case, the bass should have been sold as a second, or a “blem”. I have no idea what you paid, but if you paid full retail, I would ask for a discount, or return it.
My oldest daughter has a birthmark on her back. It was there when she was “new”. Because of her many wonderful attributes, her husband decided to keep her anyway and they are very happy together.
I have imperfections. Every manmade thing I have, and that you will ever have will have imperfections - it's just a matter of how closely you look. The question is - is it fit for purpose? Is it a good musical instrument? Given that you have said so, I'd be inclined to call it mine (with an easy way to identify it as mine should that ever come up) and move on.
I used to think these weren’t issues big enough to make waves, however, if we keep swallowing crap, they won’t improve QC.
if we demand perfection we just might get it. Imagine Fenders response if GC et al had 50% returns or downgraded to charge to Fender for small imperfections on new instruments. Better QC would be forced by the consumer.
it’s ok to dream.
if we demand perfection we just might get it. Imagine Fenders response if GC et al had 50% returns or downgraded to charge to Fender for small imperfections on new instruments. Better QC would be forced by the consumer.
it’s ok to dream.
Hummergeist
Commercial User
- Jul 21, 2020
- 1,269
- 3,084
- Disclosures
- Tutorials, reviews, and interviews for Future Publishing.
Agree, I think if you get to the point where you're asking this question, it should go back, and you'll be happier in the long run. Although a good Plan B might be to complain and try to get a partial discount/refund.
