• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Too Many Knobs vs. Not Enough Knobs

Phil Lesh has entered the chat

PhilLeshBass.jpeg
 
If you’re saying that you are unsubscribing, I’m not sure why you felt that it was necessary to state that.
I see you took it as an opportunity to troll me further :rolleyes:. Hope you enjoyed it.

You’re probably one of the “too many knobs for me” folks, aren’t you?
Nah. But, feel to add me and whoever else you perceive as treating you unfairly to your ignore list.

:sleep:
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: ebozzz
I am going to put this question in the category of gratuitous sharing of pet peeves. IMHO of course so YMMV.

TB is an internet forum. The whole idea is we get to express our opinion. So I don't see the problem with anyone writing: “Too many knobs for me.” In fact, I would be surprised if the response was not posted, since we all have different ideas of perfection.

For the record my #1 has 5 knobs and a switch. My #2 has 4 knobs and a switch. If you think that is not enough knobs, great! If you think that is too many knobs, great! Your entitled to your opinion, but don't expect it to have any bearing on what I think about my basses.
Wise words.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wasnex
Enough knobs (my favorite build config):

controls.jpg


Knobs, clockwise from top:
  • Volume
  • Blend
  • Stacked Treble / Bass boost/cut
  • Stacked Mids boost/cut / freq sweep
Switches:
  • Per pickup:
    • Series / Parallel / Outer Single Coil
  • Overall
    • Series / Parallel between pickups
    • Phase between pickups.
"Just Enough", in other words.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HaphAsSard
I’m just curious as to why some of those who seem to prefer less controls find it necessary to frequently state, “Too many knobs for me.”.?
It's an internet discussion forum... people are discussing. That's the whole point.
People are trying to contribute, maybe some people just aren't good at discussing. :cool:

I'm a HS teacher, and my school has a big focus on this right now. We call it Habits of Discussion.
There is a instigator (or as we say, an OP)
Then you can be a builder (agree) or a challenger (disagree).

In my classroom, I would tell the "Too many knobs for me" person that they need to explain themselves.
"Too many knobs for me BECAUSE..."
 
  • Like
Reactions: ebozzz
It's an internet discussion forum... people are discussing. That's the whole point.
People are trying to contribute, maybe some people just aren't good at discussing. :cool:

I'm a HS teacher, and my school has a big focus on this right now. We call it Habits of Discussion.
There is a instigator (or as we say, an OP)
Then you can be a builder (agree) or a challenger (disagree).

In my classroom, I would tell the "Too many knobs for me" person that they need to explain themselves.
"Too many knobs for me BECAUSE..."

Great points but in the discussions that I’m referring to, the “too many knobs for me” response isn’t really relevant to the topic. It seems to be more of an attitude of the responder of an attempt to slight someone or imply that they are somehow better than the person who has more. I used the following example in an attempt to explain.

A person acquires a new bass or has one that they feel really good about. A picture of the instrument is shared along with some commentary related to how they feel about their instrument. They don’t suggest that anyone needs to make a similar acquisition. They’re simply pleased with their bass.

Inevitably someone, and often multiple individuals, will post the knobs statement. Why can’t they just let the person who is happy with their bass live? Now, if someone had suggested that someone needed to add that type of bass I could better understand the response. Personally, I would just avoid saying anything if it wasn’t my preference unless I was asked for my thoughts directly.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: M-Mittlesteadt
My perfect bass gets the sound I want without touching any knobs at all. Same with my amp. Sounding great with everything at 12 o'clock is the right amp for me.

On most gigs I only use the master volume on the amp.

I use a similar methodology but I also familiarize myself with the controls on my amps & instruments so that I have the ability to make the necessary adjustments if needed. And, if I’m using an active bass I can normally make those adjustments from the onboard preamp without too much trouble.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: chris_b