This is about the best thread on transcribing that I could find quickly by searching. I just finished my first transcription, Miles' solo on "So What" off Kind of Blue. It took me about a half a week of a few hours a day at work (easy job), sitting with a CD player and a virtual piano on my phone, plinking away. I know this isn't ideal and that I should be with my bass or guitar, but it's the most fun I've had in awhile passing the time away at my lame job. The last time I took lessons - at least a few years ago - my teacher was encouraging me to transcribe, and this solo was the first piece I had started on, so I have a nice sense of accomplishment.
I am very well aware that this is probably one of the most easily accessible transcribed pieces of music - I think I had found 2 or 3 versions just searching "jazz transcriptions" on Google and I have seen a video version on YouTube. But this has me thinking - if (!) I make a habit of this and get some stuff done, I know it's not bass but do you think there would be enough interest to make it worth starting a blog or page somewhere? I've never been able to commit well to practice and I don't have great chops but I love theory and I have a ball working with sheet music, it's like a puzzle to me. Just an idea, and I don't mean to steal the concept from anyone.
I hate to say that I have skipped Coltrane and Cannonball's solos on "So What" and moved on to "Freddie Freeloader," just because the timing on a lot of the sax work seemed too complicated for now. I felt like a challenge and started in on Wynton Kelly's solo, and it took a good half hour to get the first 4 measures or so. Sixteenth triplets are a little beyond me.
One question about timing - is it okay to estimate or approximate timing when it seems hard to get down exactly? I vaguely recall my teacher telling me that it's fine at least sometimes because of the nature of jazz and swing feeling. In Miles' solo, I was able to get everything down with mostly eighths and a few triplet figures.
Edit: Does anyone have advice on figuring out chords or pieces of chords on piano? The solo is mostly single-note lines for the first chorus, but now I'm hearing chords.