The Hipshot pops were the first on the scene - the Gotoh's are fairly recent. Back before either, a used set were around $250 - now they are at least double that. I had two sets custom made by a guy that used to sell on eBay from the south. He would take what's now considered "Geddy Lee" Fender clovers and grind the top hump off and polish the edges. They look real good and were about $120 or less if you sent him the tuners.
These are them - pretty much like the Gotoh's look. If you look at the E tuner paddle - you can barely see the center of the top reflection difference. Only if you look close in certain light could anyone discern that.
View attachment 4441765
View attachment 4441767
I have the other set on my T2K MkII (Tele 2000) G&L L2000/Fender '51-P RI hybrid. MkII because it went through two variations.
View attachment 4441782