Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
What Are Your Reasons For Not Singing While Playing?
- Thread starter mrjim123
- Start date
-
- Tags
- singing and playing
I’m not a strong vocalist. I wish I was because I enjoy singing. It’s just best that I don’t.
When I went back to college as an adult I signed up for a chorus class. I thought that would be my ticket to a better voice. Surely I’d get some coaching that would carry over to singing my favorite songs. After the first day of class the instructor asked me to stay behind to work at the piano with another student. After a while the instructor said something along the lines of “That was fascinating. I’ve never heard anyone with such a narrow vocal range. I’d recommend you find another class that you’d be interested in.” I dropped chorus.
When I went back to college as an adult I signed up for a chorus class. I thought that would be my ticket to a better voice. Surely I’d get some coaching that would carry over to singing my favorite songs. After the first day of class the instructor asked me to stay behind to work at the piano with another student. After a while the instructor said something along the lines of “That was fascinating. I’ve never heard anyone with such a narrow vocal range. I’d recommend you find another class that you’d be interested in.” I dropped chorus.
I've never personally witnessed anyone who couldn't, learn to.
it's typically something some can do and some can't do.
I've never had a problem.
Not saying I'm a great singer, but decent.
it's typically something some can do and some can't do.
I've never had a problem.
Not saying I'm a great singer, but decent.
Oldish rehearsal recording, no tracks, just one mic in the room and hit it to save our arrangement.I've never personally witnessed anyone who couldn't, learn to.
it's typically something some can do and some can't do.
I've never had a problem.
Not saying I'm a great singer, but decent.
Mellowed out version of "Don't Let The Sun"
Sounds like the guitar lead was made on the spot, but that's okay, it's not for others' ears.
Me playing my totally-made-up bass line and singing lead, main singer doing backups.
Last edited:
i love to sing, and i love to play the bass. i prefer to do one or the other as to immerse myself in whichever i do, which gives me so much more satisfaction. also when playing bass, i like to wander around the stage and do some of my stage moves, while when singing leads, i feel the need to present in a more front-facing way.
I could sing back in my teens, but now, in my later 40's, I can sing about as well as I can skateboard. In either situation, I'm sure I'd injure myself.
Anyway, last time I tried to sing and play, I either started singing the bassline or started playing the vocals on the bass.
Anyway, last time I tried to sing and play, I either started singing the bassline or started playing the vocals on the bass.
Same reason I don't play bass and drums at the same time. I'm a bass player, not a singer (nor a drummer). I've toyed with singing and playing, but until I have a good reason to, it's going to be hard to dedicate the time to really master it.
my reason is for concentrate my bass line , and of course to keep the tempo , because sometimes we out of the tempo while we sing at the same time. and maybe you should choose when the part that you should go sing
Singing and playing bass has gotten me gigs over a lot better bass players who don’t sing. I’m not a great lead singer but I can sing some good leads if I choose my songs well, and I’m quite good at harmonies. If I have trouble singing and playing a song, I either work it out or I don’t sing on that song. 99% of the time I work it out. That’s why I get the slightly better than average bucks 
I'm the primary backing vocalist in my band. Honestly, I wish I wasn't, but I'm pretty decent at harmonies, and my voice seems to gel really well with our singer.
I don't actually mind singing while playing in general, but I dislike being glued to the mic stand for many sections of almost every song, and not being able to move around freely.
I don't actually mind singing while playing in general, but I dislike being glued to the mic stand for many sections of almost every song, and not being able to move around freely.
I can sing well, or I can play bass well. Pick one, but I can't do both at the same time. My neuro pathways don't like to cross streams, it's like Ghostbusters.
Because I've been cursed with the most heinous voice in the history of the human race (and some other species, too).
Given that I can't sing without playing... i don't think adding the bass on top would help much
While I've experienced some of your argument about singing while playing diluting your playing (I also believe it dilutes the singing).
My stipulation is: I can't sing harmonies. I've never been able to sing harmonies reliably. I just can't. I guess my ear just gravitates toward the melody.
I have/can/will sing leads or back-up vocals which are unison; not harmonies.
I guess it comes from some of my bass influences, when I first started who also sang (and my being the singer in my band); one of the main ones being Geddy Lee.
My stipulation is: I can't sing harmonies. I've never been able to sing harmonies reliably. I just can't. I guess my ear just gravitates toward the melody.
I have/can/will sing leads or back-up vocals which are unison; not harmonies.
I guess it comes from some of my bass influences, when I first started who also sang (and my being the singer in my band); one of the main ones being Geddy Lee.
1) bad sounds come out when i open my face
For me, it's the other end that's the problem.1) bad sounds come out when i open my face
