Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
What is the 'old' TalkBass?
- Thread starter tb-player
- Start date
People were meaner back in the day lol
It's less active now but I think better honestly
It's less active now but I think better honestly
Now it's "How much does it weigh?"
Old bassists have age related issues.
I believe the forum remains relatively constant.
The people change. We lose some, gain others. Our greater society changes; and thus the nature of the gigs changes with our society. We see those changes in the contributed comments.
For example, I started participating in 2002; and one of my first contentious exchanges was over the then MTV cultural pressure that young women should be sexually available for any and all male advances. I took exception to this offensive (IMO) cultural twist at the time. MTV is now gone; and I believe we have made some progress on the social gender front.
If anything, our forum moderators have become more conscientious with rule enforcement, keeping discussions focused on making music.
TalkBass is a well run forum, which eschews the (highly) flawed Silicon Valley business model of trafficking in personal information. We should be so lucky.
The people change. We lose some, gain others. Our greater society changes; and thus the nature of the gigs changes with our society. We see those changes in the contributed comments.
For example, I started participating in 2002; and one of my first contentious exchanges was over the then MTV cultural pressure that young women should be sexually available for any and all male advances. I took exception to this offensive (IMO) cultural twist at the time. MTV is now gone; and I believe we have made some progress on the social gender front.
If anything, our forum moderators have become more conscientious with rule enforcement, keeping discussions focused on making music.
TalkBass is a well run forum, which eschews the (highly) flawed Silicon Valley business model of trafficking in personal information. We should be so lucky.
Last edited:
The Wild West has been tamed and settled. Not bad. Just different. Like the old "How many vintage guitar dealers does it take to change a lightbulb? Two. One to change it and one to say: 'Yeah, but the old one was better.'". I appreciate the sublime combination of info, opinion, and humor!
The Bar Band Bassman
The Bar Band Bassman
I can’t even tell because I go to Home first and read the four tabbed pages which are just the latest and most active posts. I never go into the individual forums.
I've been here about 8 years or so. Web-based forums (fora?) just continue to become dinosaurs as more and more people like to use dedicated social media platforms such as Reddit, etc. I have been active in other forums and they similarly have dwindled. It is older folks like me that "grew up" on web-based fora that still use them. Just a fact of life.
Other comments: I am sure the moderation is effective in making this still a good forum. Also, "PC" means a lot of different things to different people, so that isn't a good way to describe something, IMHO.
Other comments: I am sure the moderation is effective in making this still a good forum. Also, "PC" means a lot of different things to different people, so that isn't a good way to describe something, IMHO.
.
I've done some analysis and can confirm that indeed the "old" TalkBass was far superior to what we have now.
I had an account under an email address that I lost access to (started around 2007ish) so I made a new one shortly thereafter. While this one started in 2010, I've got more years on here than 14 (like anyone is impressed lol).
There's a bit more civility now, but I'd actually say that happened organically with knowledgeable veterans and cooler heads sticking around. Instead of being simply berated for asking a common question, people now often suggest a thread search or give some insight on how to find the answer or the right question to ask (the old "Best Bass for Metal" or "Tube vs. Solid State Watts" questions). "Underpowering Speakers" was something I mistakenly took as true, but asking here, it was tactfully shown how it doesn't hold up to factual scrutiny.
I'll leave specific examples out, but what wasn't present (or less visible to me) in the "old days" was some of the self-appointed policing by non-Admins. I don't feel there was a lack of consideration in the "old days", but over time there were more people seeking something to make an issue of. I got stories...but I'll just leave the past in the past (or archived threads lol).
There's a bit more civility now, but I'd actually say that happened organically with knowledgeable veterans and cooler heads sticking around. Instead of being simply berated for asking a common question, people now often suggest a thread search or give some insight on how to find the answer or the right question to ask (the old "Best Bass for Metal" or "Tube vs. Solid State Watts" questions). "Underpowering Speakers" was something I mistakenly took as true, but asking here, it was tactfully shown how it doesn't hold up to factual scrutiny.
I'll leave specific examples out, but what wasn't present (or less visible to me) in the "old days" was some of the self-appointed policing by non-Admins. I don't feel there was a lack of consideration in the "old days", but over time there were more people seeking something to make an issue of. I got stories...but I'll just leave the past in the past (or archived threads lol).
My first thought was the old TalkBass was a bulletin board called “The Bottom Line” which started in 1993 by a college kid named Erik Habinga. It was all new - this internet thing and an amazing time. Jeff Berlin, Carol Kaye and Chuck Rainey posted quite often. There were organized collaborative cassette releases of bass players music, and endless discussion about - is an electric bass really just a guitar? There was one troll by the name of “fingers” who was chastising everyone for the forum just being a shopping site and not about bass playing. Was he wrong? I believe the term GAS started on that site.
Anyone else remember it?
Anyone else remember it?
How you're still here is beyond me.
My major malfunction time here was solved by only logging in sporadically during a roughly 2year period.
And not being a daily poster for a long time.
I was in my early 40's when I joined and now coming up on 70, my opinions on a few things have changed.
.
This is pretty much it. 20 year club and figure the root is engagement, the variables come with increased engagement. I'll sat, I don't engage like I did 20 years ago. I love this place though.
