• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

What is the 'old' TalkBass?

I've been here about 8 years or so. Web-based forums (fora?) just continue to become dinosaurs as more and more people like to use dedicated social media platforms such as Reddit, etc. I have been active in other forums and they similarly have dwindled. It is older folks like me that "grew up" on web-based fora that still use them. Just a fact of life.

Other comments: I am sure the moderation is effective in making this still a good forum. Also, "PC" means a lot of different things to different people, so that isn't a good way to describe something, IMHO.

Yeah, I said PC a page or two ago, but for me that is really proxy for being more polite and consistent (that's still PC... happy accident).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5StringBlues
I have seen a number of references to the 'old' TalkBass recently... "missing the 'old' TalkBass..." "the 'old' TalkBass was better..." etc.

I joined TalkBass in 2019. And over the last 5 years I've noticed no significant changes in TB. I can only assume I am a part of the 'new' TalkBass; the one that isn't as good as its predecessor.

Can someone please explain to me how the 'old' and 'new' TalkBass differ? When did it change? And why it's not as good as it used to be?
much less members. more of a close knit community.
 
I first joined in 2004 and was around for some of the legendary trolls (e.g. NickTheBassist) and the earth-shatteringly controversial actions (e.g. banning Ken Smith and Jeff Berlin).

I don't feel like the vibe has changed all that much. We still have our people we get along with and people who like to rile others up. We still have those who willingly lend a helping hand to a question asked for the umpteenth time and those who bark, "do a search!" We have those who offer insight into a topic and those who just jump into say inflammatory stuff to cut the OP or other people down. We have those who embrace modernism and those who still cling steadfastly to the tried 'n true "old ways."

To me, it's just like any community, be it online, in school, in your town, etc.

One difference I see is that we have fewer "flavor of the month" zeitgeists. Like I remember a period of time in my early days (early 2000s) when it felt like everyone clowned on Warwick (calling them Warwank), Ibanez (calling them I-Been-Hadz), and other brands. Probably it was because nu-metal was the dominant form of music and music elitists were all, "Bah, that ain't real music!" But then again, that elitist attitude towards modern music is still present among people.

So, yeah, to me TalkBass is still pretty much how it's always been as far as I know. And maybe my mentality and mindset have changed (I was 26 then and am 45 now).

And from then until now, I've met some wonderful people in person thanks to the classifieds. Ergo, TalkBass feels like more than just an online forum. It really is a community. Like, wow, I actually shook hands with some of the people here. They're not just words on a screen, they're people.
 
Last edited: