• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

What would you do? (Ethical question)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Once they do an inventory, determine they are short they will look for things like duplicate shipments. Legally they can charge your CC as you received their property and didn't bring it to their attention.
If you don't want the material they will instruct you to leave it on your front porch, or with a neighbor for pick up the next day. UPS and Fedex have services exactly for this.
If you want a back up I'd explain the situation and they will extend you a huge discount that will make you happy.
Remember that their job isn't to hastle you with unexpected shipments - but to make you a satisfied customer.

Legally they CANNOT charge you for something that they sent you that you did not order. That's mail fraud. Got a free Fender P from zZounds that way.
 
I SO wish this is an accurate representation of the world population ...

How do you deal with pricing mistake in a music store?
Say an MIA P is marked with the price of an MIM huh?

How many will take advantage of another's mistake?

That is different. Negotiating a price is just as much seller beware as buyer beware. And sellers sometimes deliberately lose on a given deal, in order to encourage other aspects of the business.
 
Zzounds sent you a bass by mistake?

Yup. They called me about 18 months later, asking me how I'd like to pay for it. I told her what she was doing was mail fraud. She put me on hold for 10 seconds, came back and said, "Alright sir, we'll take care of that for you. You have a nice day". She hung up before I could even say thank you. Never heard from them again, not even a catalog.
 
hmm it's also easy to say things like "its the right thing to do, return it" but would you really if you were in the OP's shoes?

I ordered a camera a few years ago from Amazon. It never came, so I called them and they shipped another one. Months later, lo and behold, the camera arrives on my doorstep. At first, I was all like " Suckas !" But after a day or so, my conscious got me, I called `em, they were pleasantly surprised at my honesty. They asked me to pay for return shipping and credited my account for the amount.
 
I can't think of a single valid reason to send it back. It's not like MF is a paragoon of morality in the first place or is going to miss the money.
Hell, if your conscience prevents you from keeping it as a backup, give it away to somebody who really needs an amp. I'd probably do that.
 
I can't think of a single valid reason to send it back. It's not like MF is a paragoon of morality in the first place or is going to miss the money.
Hell, if your conscience prevents you from keeping it as a backup, give it away to somebody who really needs an amp. I'd probably do that.

+1

MF properly got insurance for that kind of incidences too, so actually it's the moralless insurance companies that suffers, and they can properly write it all off in taxes anyhow by some loop hole in the law.
So in that way we are all paying for you taking that amp. That's not fair.... But since we are so many of us, I'll let you have this one.

Go for it, take it... You know you want to!



join the dark side

*MuAhaHaHaaa*
 
+2. This thread has been a great way to compile a list of TB'ers with whom I will or will not conduct classifieds business.

I agree. My comments were in jest, for those who don't understand internet emoticons. ;)

dmusic148, why don't you become a Supporting Member, while you are checking out the classifieds? ;) :cool:
 
+2. This thread has been a great way to compile a list of TB'ers with whom I will or will not conduct classifieds business.

Question: if you list a bass for $300 when you meant $500,
and it is not a typo but your error,
And someone calls you and says "I'll take it"...

Who is the dishonest person in the transaction if you refuse to sell to him for that price??
 
coyote1 said:
Question: if you list a bass for $300 when you meant $500,
and it is not a typo but your error,
And someone calls you and says "I'll take it"...

Who is the dishonest person in the transaction if you refuse to sell to him for that price??

You are, if you are that bad at proofreading your own ad.
 
I wouldn't send it back. MF is a big organization that his made its money so many times over. Why?? I used to work a corporate job, and we used to give away so many freebies and periodically spend ridiculous $$ on dinners that consisted mostly of booze.
Executives waste even more money than I did, but consumers choose to keep giving it up.
Enjoy the bonus dude! Look at it as MF giving back to you!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.