• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Whatever happened to the Gibson Raid outcome?

I was just watching a Youtube video then saw in the related videos the Gibson raid confrence (Misspelt I know) the CEO held outside their Nashville factory. He said that the Goverment halted all Gibson production while they investigated wether Gibson's woods were legally obtained.

Well Gibson is making guitars again so what happened did the DA drop the case on Gibby or did Gibby get it all squared away with Uncle Sam?

I think the woods in question were Rosewood and Ebony acquired from India and Madagascar respectivly.
 
"They...come in with weapons, they seized a half-million dollars worth of property, they shut our factory down, and they have not charged us with anything," says Gibson Guitars CEO Henry Juszkiewicz, referring to the August 2011 raid on his Nashville and Memphis factories by agents from the Departments of Homeland Security and Fish & Wildlife.

The feds raided Gibson for using an inappropriate tariff code on wood from India, which is a violation of the anti-trafficking statute known as The Lacey Act. At issue is not whether the wood in question was endangered, but whether the wood was the correct level of thickness and finish before being exported from India. "India is wanting to ensure that raw wood is not exported without some labor content from India," says Juskiewicz.

Andrea Johnson of the Environmental Investigation Agency (EIA) counters that "it's not up to Gibson to decide which laws...they want to respect." She points out that Gibson had previously been raided under The Lacey Act for imports from Madagascar.

This much is clear: The government has yet to file any charges or allow Gibson a day in court to makes its case, much less retrieve its materials. "This is not about responsible forestry and sustainable wood or illegal logging, this is about a bureaucratic law," argues Juszkiewicz, who testified last year before a congressional hearing convened by Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.). It is, he says, "a blank check for abuse."

About 6 minutes. Written, produced, and narrated by Anthony L. Fisher; shot by Joshua Swain.

The Great Gibson Guitar Raid: Months Later, Still No Charges Filed - YouTube

Invalid Link Removed
 
ok then why would the government seize the product and not charge the offender?

I'm not sure. Could be that they could prove the woods were illegally obtained, but couldn't prove Gibson knowingly pursued illegal material. Usually the offending goods are simply seized and there is no criminal charge unless there is strong evidence of a plot to deceive.
 
I saw an article on Monday .. and maybe on You-tube with Rand Paul describing NEW legislation that will exclude the USA form adhering to other coutrys laws in regards to provisions in the Lacy agreement so that companies such as Gibson will not be hunted down and deprived their due Process.. Im sure there is something about it in a Rand Paul site somewhere..