CP, let me know your thoughts about your Stereo Memory Man over your Memory Toy
I actually liked the EXH Memory Toy quite a bit (still have it in my house, but it is sold). I know others have mentioned the modulation feature being totally whacked and unusable (and some YouTube clips confirm that), but I guess mine had the trim pot adjusted correctly since I preferred having the mod on. The modulation is much more subtle on mine, adding just a bit of sparkle and shimmer. To be honest, the main reason why I bought it at first was that the nano size meant I could fit it on to my board at the time. But I really loved it once I had it on there.
The Stereo Memory Man came into play only because I saw one on Craigslist (damn GAS), and the more I researched it, considered it's looping options, tap tempo, preset saving options, etc, the more seriously I considered it. The issue of board space was solved when I decided I could also live without the Small Stone Nano to make room for it.
My main worry was the "digital" aspect of the Stereo Memory Man. I recently had a Line 6 Echo Park and brought that back to the store within 48 hours ... lots of nice options on the Echo Park but definitely prefered the anolog tone on the Memory Toy, and hated the "clinical tone" of the Echo Park.
Now I've only been playing around with the SMM for a couple of hours now ... just in a room with myself, I admit I prefer the tone of the Memory Toy (especially my fave setting with Delay and Blend at 10 or 11 O'clock and Feedback at 12). The anolog pedal just has this deeper ominous church-like tone to it.
With that said, the SMM sounds incredible in it's own right ... and I can get close enough to an analog tone (wayyyyy warmer than the Echo Park IMO), I now have many more options available to me and I think the "cleaner / crisper / tighter" tone of the SSM will be preferable to me in a full band setting. I think my ears are still calibrated for analog (lol), but I'm really enjoying what I'm hearing from the SMM.
A bit of an apples and oranges comparison of course in terms of size , digital vs. analog, and price (!)... but all in all considering the total package, the bells and whistles, and what I want on my board, the Stereo Memory Man is everything I was hoping it would be and more. Everything it does, it does very well! The Memory Toy was also everything I was hoping it to be, and is relatively wallet friendly. The one thing it does, it does very well!