What it really boils down to, is that the original question should not be, "Why are 5s or 6s better?" The question should be, "Why are 5's and 6's better for those of you who play them?"
I just started playing again two years ago after a 14 year hiatus (mid 80's). That was about when the 5's started to become more popular.
When I started playing again, I couldn't understand why bass players needed 6 or 7 strings. I thought it was some kind of cheap manhood statement. I also thought that the guys playing them were frustrated guitarists.
Now that I have been playing for about two years again, I've had the opportunity to play some 5's and 6's. I like them, they don't feel too bulky to me, and I like the idea of not having to run up and down the fingerboard so frequently. It actually feels more comfortable for me than a 4. I have small hands (make any joke you want but I'm not going there), but I don't have to stretch my fingers on a 5 or a 6 like I do on a 4.
I'm no great player. I'm not Patucci, Claypool or any of those other great multistringed bassists, but I feel that I can handle a 5 or a 6 comfortably. I'm not trying to make a statement or trying to look better than I am. I just want an instrument that I feel comfortable with.
So go and get yourself a 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 or even a 12 if it feels good to you. Don't let anyone tell you what you SHOULD be playing. That's down right close minded and stupid.
I just started playing again two years ago after a 14 year hiatus (mid 80's). That was about when the 5's started to become more popular.
When I started playing again, I couldn't understand why bass players needed 6 or 7 strings. I thought it was some kind of cheap manhood statement. I also thought that the guys playing them were frustrated guitarists.
Now that I have been playing for about two years again, I've had the opportunity to play some 5's and 6's. I like them, they don't feel too bulky to me, and I like the idea of not having to run up and down the fingerboard so frequently. It actually feels more comfortable for me than a 4. I have small hands (make any joke you want but I'm not going there), but I don't have to stretch my fingers on a 5 or a 6 like I do on a 4.
I'm no great player. I'm not Patucci, Claypool or any of those other great multistringed bassists, but I feel that I can handle a 5 or a 6 comfortably. I'm not trying to make a statement or trying to look better than I am. I just want an instrument that I feel comfortable with.
So go and get yourself a 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 or even a 12 if it feels good to you. Don't let anyone tell you what you SHOULD be playing. That's down right close minded and stupid.