I think the entire genre died once it became apparent that TBers couldn't answer the question, "What's the best bass for metal?"
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Where are the metal bands?
- Thread starter Thomas Kievit
- Start date
I wonder how much of that can be blamed on the record producers too. I mean, if they're producing a sound that doesn't sell, why are all the new groups copping the same sounds? Just from my time on TB, I see there's a lot of new, young talent that is in love with the Metal genre. So why no new megagroups? Maybe the Metal labels need some new talent at the mixing desk.
Looking at all of the latest press on metal blogs I'd say that the new bands are being choked off by all the old bands that are dropping in once every five years to do a tour or release something to keep the brand afloat. The labels are just like the big Hollywood studios, they'd rather spend a few bucks backing a known quantity with an existing audience than putting any money behind a fresh new act that could flop or flash out. Smaller pie and more old bands grabbing a piece = no pie for new bands. The classic risk-averse behavior of a shrinking and top-heavy media market.
No more new rock stars.
But outside the mainstream there is a lot of good metal coming out.
No more new rock stars.
But outside the mainstream there is a lot of good metal coming out.
Metal seems to have divided into a million little niches. I could name some great bands in a lot of those niches but I can't name too many bands that transcend those niches (minus the couple that have been mentioned). I don't like all of these niches and I think that is kind of the point, something for everybody. On the other hand, it would be nice to have a couple of big metal bands that everyone could sing along with.
Some of the bands in the stoner rock/metal scene are doing some interesting stuff and seem to be gaining a fair bit of popularity. I'm personally digging Baroness and Red Fang.
Same here. Over the past few years, The Sword and Red Fang have been the two newer heavy bands that I really dig. They can play, they can sing, and they don't look like idiots in Halloween costumes or have a lot of the cheese associated with some metal. i think the whole Stoner Rock scene has had the coolest heavy bands over the past 10 years.
Last edited:
I think all the BIG New metal bands are hanging around the same places as the BIG new jazz bands...
Yeah, I was going to say Mastodon...they seem like one of the few bands that could take Metallica's place.
My singer told me to get into white wizard last month & I'm enjoying them quite abit. Don't know how old they are or anything. But I think there worth checking out if you like classic metal.
I don't really need bands to become as big as Metallica once was.
Sure I want then to continue to make music and be self supporting. I just don't need 1 single killer band. I'd rather have 100 above average metal bands touring large clubs than 1 arena-level band.
Sure I want then to continue to make music and be self supporting. I just don't need 1 single killer band. I'd rather have 100 above average metal bands touring large clubs than 1 arena-level band.
New metal bands?
Well, you got Trivium, Meshuggah, Mastodon, the revitalized Queensrÿche, Bad Salad, Periphery, Newsted, Skeletonwitch...
Well, you got Trivium, Meshuggah, Mastodon, the revitalized Queensrÿche, Bad Salad, Periphery, Newsted, Skeletonwitch...
The new accept albums have been pretty solid aswell. I know there not a new band. But there come back has been pretty bad arse.
Don't we already have that? It'd be nice to have at least a handful of new metal bands breakthrough to the mainstream and have some representation there. I guess a lot of metal fans like being underground and obscure, but I don't.
Music isn't a popularity contest for me. I just want some heavy music. I've been refusing to listen to radio for at least 5 years so I don't expect to hear new stuff there. I started listening to Pandora, Spotify, Google Music, and lately Bandcamp.
Sure I work harder to find good stuff but is not really that hard.
Found this on Pandora and LMAO.
Heard about this one here and likewise LMAO.
Invalid Link Removed
Neither is really radio material is "comedic heavy music." Where is the revenue stream with that?
Who cares though I've got stuff to rock out to.
Ha! I love to hear the younger players whining about their favorite genre disappearing. Sorry, guys, but that is the way it is. Other genres you don' hear any more:
Times change, music progresses and replaces old style. Learn to live with it. Some day your kids will think you are outdated for still wanting to play "that old metal crap".
- When was the last time you heard a band to a disco album?
- How long since a doo-wap group did an alubm?
- Name a folk rock group that is touring.
Times change, music progresses and replaces old style. Learn to live with it. Some day your kids will think you are outdated for still wanting to play "that old metal crap".
You have to remember that Metallica were really the first band with "extreme" metal subculture roots (i.e. the subculture of thrash) to go mega-global. So in that respect they are kind of unique, as that moment in time has now passed.
What's happened today is that the GENRE of metal is bigger than ever - huge festivals, loads of fans, quite a lot of bands with a good mid-level following, and a LOT of bands barely scraping by, commercially, but making great music. You're correct in that really only the "heritage" acts are filling stadiums (ironically, Metallica are now in this category).
But there's still plenty of good stuff out there that's getting commercial success (especially in continental Europe and America), starting with Mastodon at the top and moving downward from there. My current favourites are Kvelertak, check 'em out!
What's happened today is that the GENRE of metal is bigger than ever - huge festivals, loads of fans, quite a lot of bands with a good mid-level following, and a LOT of bands barely scraping by, commercially, but making great music. You're correct in that really only the "heritage" acts are filling stadiums (ironically, Metallica are now in this category).
But there's still plenty of good stuff out there that's getting commercial success (especially in continental Europe and America), starting with Mastodon at the top and moving downward from there. My current favourites are Kvelertak, check 'em out!
