• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Which Ibanez to choose?

Matthew Bryson said:
I love my EDB605 (Ergodyne) It's a great bass.

You'll get plenty of hard headed traditionalists bashing Ibanez (probably because it's a foreign company) and they'll really bash the non traditional materials (luthite) but really, most of them haven't even played one and are just regurgitating what they've heard from others - a lot of what you read (re: EDB & EDA) is based in ignorance. The haters should really stay out of Ibanez threads - if you have a problem with Ibanez stuff, don't respond to a 'which Ibanez' thread :spit: my $.02

I play an EDA905F, myself, and a Lakland Skyline 5 (Fretted). I've played a wide variety of fours (I miss my Vox Phantom - [sniff]), and I have to say that I love the sound of my EDA with good strings. Right now it has a set of Ken Smiths on it and I like how they sound, but they're chewing up the fingerboard. Anyhoo...

I respectfully disagree about the "haters" staying out of these discussions. Someone who is just going to be negative without foundation or reason for it *should* probably keep quiet (but probably won't ;) ), but a person who has had a bad experience or three with Ibanez might have something valuable to contribute.

This is gettin' long... let me cut to it. My EDA is a wonderful instrument, and I enjoy it a lot, but it could be a lot better. My other Ibanez bass was an old replica of the Gibson Flying V as a bass (I've never seen a real Gibson Flying V Bass... did one exist?). It had a lovely froggy tone, but the neck rapidly bowed to the point that the intonation was shot no matter what I did. I wound up trading it for a small amp.

It's worth noting that Ibanez has discontinued the EDA. I wonder why?
 
I cant believe Ibanez recently discontinued the EDA, I love my EDA905 (RRF is the best colour for it ever :p ) , the only thing i think would be better is if they used a better magnetic pup, but i could sort that myself, i also have a BTB406QM, and yeah, you can get alot of sounds out of it, but i just love the sound i get from my EDA, some ppl will say its an aquired taste, but ive loved it from the moment i picked it up in the shop, you really do need to play about with the "set n forget" controls a bit tho

personally i think the SR's are horrendous, not tried the really high up models tho, the SRX's are better, and i love the ATK's, i really want one! i also have an ibanez Tr50, which i got for £50 in a pawn shop, it was minging and scabby, but it still sounds good :p
 
I own an SR300DX , and just bought a Fender standard Precision Bass (MIM). From all the talk I had to at least have a fender. The fender is a fine piece of craftsmanship, nice wood, finish, hardware etc.

But..... I prefer the Ibanez over it for sound, feel, looks, and playability. I plan to keep both, but I would sell the fender before I sold the Ibanez. It may be the only perfect SR300DX made, I dont know, But I love this bass