• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

White or black bass?

White or black

  • White

    Votes: 174 51.8%
  • Black

    Votes: 162 48.2%

  • Total voters
    336
Grand piano black, is sort of more timeless than white. Me thinks. I don't care, but I think dings and dents shows up equally as bad on black or white. Apart from this if either has "old school" nitrocellulose lacquer the dings turns up sooner anyway regardless of white, black or any other color. I have had all basses, but some basses seems to just aesthetically seems to be better off to come with a certain flavor. Steinberger, or graphite basses, I prefer the black variants of it. Same with telecaster basses, they just should come with butterscotch blonde and black pickguard. Black is a color that is less time, fashion, period dependent, and NOT just for metal or hard rock. It's never ever been a deal breaker for me, any color. Recently I missed out on a white Dingwall bass (J bass) from Germanys Session Music, through the internet shop. It was sold at the same time, to another one, and they hadn't updated the site. FWIW, I do think some shapes and forms of basses - sometimes - "calls" for a certain color to be slightly more suitable than any other. When gigging I always found grand piano black basses can come across as more "classy" in some settings, espeically at gigs, where there's a dress code.

It' the same with acoustic guitars. For some strange reason, the maple fretboard on any acoustic guitar looks just a little bit too left, and weird, in spite of it being actually better quality wise, than any other wood.

If I see a black bass, it's no big deal. Or white. But black block inlays on fretboard gives me the shivers.... don't know why, at all, but some kind of tackiness, or kitsch starts to creep in. Carpentry showoff. I don't know, but having large blocks (any) in the fretboard isn't my kind. It's different than wood, and reacts differently than wood to season changes and truss rod changes, as well as feel. I want wood feel under my fingers. But this is OT. Now back to the script.

- - - - - - - - -

One of my friends had a RED Yamaha short grand piano. Acoustic. Resident in living room. He got incredibly fatigued by the look of it during the course of the years. Instead of selling it, and buying a new black one, he had it all re-painted! Grand piano black. Still after a few years, it hasn't started to wear on his eyes yet. YMMV. Each to their own. His kids thought it was boring with black, and loved the shiny bright red instead...;-) It seems that black has the upper hand of white, in terms of longevity.
 
I like white and black bodies.
But it's key what color pickguards and fretboards you pair with them.
White body with white guard and a maple fretboard/neck.
White body with tort guard and a rosewood or maple fretboard/neck.
Black body with tort guard (red or brown) and rosewood fretboard.
Black body with no guard and maple fretboard/neck and all black hardware too.
Black body with gold pearloid guard and rosewood fretboard.
 
Black has my preference, but I'd play a white bass too if I like how it sounds and plays.
I tend to like the black keys on a keyboard better than the white ones too.



"Ich warte taste schwarze Tasten
weil Weiss bisher nur irrt

I'm waiting touching black keys
because white as yet is wrong"

Ich Warte, Einstürzende Neubauten
 
Both!

image.jpeg
 
My preference is for the natural wood finish but I bought this black one a few years ago and man has it got an amazing sound. I think I would still have bought it if it was white but if I had a choice of two the same I'd go for the black one.
Initially I was put off by the colour but it sounds amazing so i've grown used to it. I have been thinking of having the paint removed as I have seen the build pictures and it has a lovely flame maple top.
83135.jpg
 
Black on black with rosewood, that has my vote! I love the look of a black p-bass with a black pickguard, with the white stripe around it. The Jaguar I'm looking at also has a black body with a black pickguard w/ a white stripe around it, with a rosewood fretboard. At one point I was into white p-basses but every time I saw one it reminded me of my black on black and I went back lol. And to the guy who said a black bass with a black shirt doesn't look good, I think it looks great! I play like that all the time