• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Who has the best online lessons nowadays?

I've tried a number of online lessons and while I do think Scottsbasslessons is decent, he spends too much time talking.

For me, I have found Truefire.com very helpful. I'm only a beginner/intermediate player. Truefire has very good video, charts and jam tracks. The instructors are clear and concise. Yes, the site is primarily a guitar site, but there are plenty of bass lessons to keep me busy for a year or more. The basic plan is only about $15 per month. I have not tried the interactive lessons.

I have taken live lessons and have mostly been disappointed. Yes, I learned a few important fundamentals, and that is hugely important to avoid developing bad habits. But it seems every teacher just had to show off for too much of the lesson, or had little interest or knowledge of the music I preferred (Americana, country, folk). Yes, that is fairly simple music for a bass player, but playing simple well and sensitively is an art.

I'm lucky that my wife is a musician, and because we play together several times a week, I do get some good musical advice, especially when I try to get "too creative". Which is another way of stating the obvious ... playing with others teaches you a lot. I also use a drum machine most of the time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bradd Szonye
Thank-you Mark for your post, a very good perspective. My problem has been finding a good teacher (good for me, that is). I am gravitating towards on-line lessons because there just aren't any good teachers that I can find.

My problems are:

-I'm an adult (over 50), and don't want to play Justin Beiber songs. Every single teacher has been a twenty-something or younger. No offence to that age group, but knowing how to play bass does not = knowing how to teach bass.
-none of the teachers I've had ever bothered to ask me what my experience was. At the first lesson they just asked me what I wanted to learn (ie: "Do you want to learn any songs of just some scales?"
- There was never any "structure" to the lessons. Some were like a "jam" session. I just became frustrated and tried to find another teacher.
-none of the teachers ever provided instruction to me on technique.

I guess what I'm saying is that all the bass instruction near me seems geared to young kids who are beginners. In fact, some of the teachers were guitar players who happened to teach bass as well.

Very frustrating.

My suggestion, Anthony Wellington.....

He's always looking out for skype students, tell him Jason sent you.

Invalid Link Removed
 
I took the Berklee Online couse titled 'R&B Bass' and it was really great. Pretty in-depth. I had been taking private lessons with the instructor, Danny Morris previously. The price tag for the course is rather steep but I figured if I had taken that many hours of lessons with Danny it would have cost more. Still, taking lessons face to face with him was better.

I would also like to mention Jamplay. Seems like a lot of heavy metal players are instructors on that site, but the non-metal instructors are pretty good. Not bad for $19.99 a month.
 
I've tried a number of online lessons and while I do think Scottsbasslessons is decent, he spends too much time talking.

For me, I have found Truefire.com very helpful. I'm only a beginner/intermediate player. Truefire has very good video, charts and jam tracks. The instructors are clear and concise. Yes, the site is primarily a guitar site, but there are plenty of bass lessons to keep me busy for a year or more. The basic plan is only about $15 per month. I have not tried the interactive lessons.

I have taken live lessons and have mostly been disappointed. Yes, I learned a few important fundamentals, and that is hugely important to avoid developing bad habits. But it seems every teacher just had to show off for too much of the lesson, or had little interest or knowledge of the music I preferred (Americana, country, folk). Yes, that is fairly simple music for a bass player, but playing simple well and sensitively is an art.

I'm lucky that my wife is a musician, and because we play together several times a week, I do get some good musical advice, especially when I try to get "too creative". Which is another way of stating the obvious ... playing with others teaches you a lot. I also use a drum machine most of the time.

Being a truefire instructor myself, I have to agree that they do a good job making sure the courses are both relevant, well thought out and done with high quality audio and video. That being said, many of the sites mentioned here have great material, it is a matter of personal taste and the learning style that fits the individual. Just like music or bass playing itself, very subjective
 
  • Like
Reactions: progrmr
Thanks for the links guys. However, I'd definitely agree that there's no substitute for a real, live teacher. For a beginner it's a must. That said, you can have terrible, live teachers just as you can have terrible online advice. Although it has to be said that a 'good teacher' can be very much in the eye of the beholder. Some of my favourite teachers at university were hated by others and we all had different opinions on them. This all depended on the musicians styles and interests. Some of us just didn't get on with certain methods and content.

I think it also depends what your goals are. Some guys just want to play for a laidback hobby and in a local band. If you took up bass because you love Cliff Burton and just want to be able to play a few Metallica tunes in your spare time it can actually be frustrating to get a teacher that wants to ram jazz harmony and reading down your throat in the manner of a Jeff Berlin type. Some teacher's have got a set idea of 'what you must learn to be a proper bass player' and that can just annoy students who'll either just go somewhere else (another teacher or online) or put them off playing altogether (if they're really touchy!). That might seem a bit of an exaggeration but I've known loads of beginner players who've complained to me about not being able to relate to certain teachers who I considered great players and, for the most part, great teachers. It's easy to blame the student for not wanting to put the time and effort in but some people just want to have a bit of fun with the instrument and don't want to spend hours working on it.

So from that perspective I'd say that online tips and lessons can be quite valuable to someone who might find it really difficult to find the right teacher or be struggling with really getting into playing after mastering the basics. Also, some players live out in the middle of nowhere. Even in somewhere quite over populated like England, it's quite possible to find yourself in a village completely devoid of bass teachers, players or any musicians at all. For those people, online lessons can be a handy way of picking up tips and piecing it all together by themselves.

That said, if you have any aspirations of being a professional musician, learning jazz improvisation, harmony, aural, sight reading or any other aspects of music that require dedicated long term practice then I'd say get a live teacher. As someone that produces online content and teaches both on skype and in person, I'd definitely say that live, hands on teaching is the easiest and best way in terms of adapting to the student, which in turn speeds up the learning process tenfold. Even little things like being able to modify a students hand position by a fraction of an inch and improve the execution of a certain line is absolutely invaluable. If you can afford it and you have access to a teacher then go for it.

Yeah, now if there actually WAS a teacher like that in the Portland, OR area who didn't charge an arm & a leg for 30 minutes worth of instruction, I'd be in phat city!
 
Yeah, now if there actually WAS a teacher like that in the Portland, OR area who didn't charge an arm & a leg for 30 minutes worth of instruction, I'd be in phat city!

I understand that sentiment, but in bass lessons and life in general, you often get what you pay for, normally not going to find the top physicians hanging out at the free clinic
 
  • Like
Reactions: SBassman
Well, I'm out shopping for an online course!

Are there any sites that propose a complete course for an intermediate bass player, possibly with personal program and feedback?

Something with a roadmap, and a system, not just isolated lessons on this and that.
 
I'd say both. Getting different perspectives is a good thing.

You can't beat in-person practice with a good teacher, but nothing says you can't watch some online videos to pick up tips here and there and then discuss them in your live lessons (speak openly about it with your teacher to avoid contradictory techniques).

I really enjoy watching the Youtube vids that both Scott Devine and Mark J. Smith put out. I've picked up some good playing tips from both of them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: exidor
Are there any sites that propose a complete course for an intermediate bass player, possibly with personal program and feedback?

Something with a roadmap, and a system, not just isolated lessons on this and that.

Scott's Bass Lessons is the closest thing to what you seem to be looking for that I have seen. I'm curious about Adam Nitti's online resource. That may be the one to check out...
 
You are right actually this really doesn´t matter. But I still think it´s something special that he became famous as a online teacher and not as a performer.

He can play! I haven't checked out his site much but I have seen several of his videos. It wasn't my intention to be offensive with my comment and please accept my apology if that's how you interpreted what I said. I think Marlowe would sound great on just about any bass. Sandberg or otherwise..... :D

I'll have to check out a his lessons a little more....