• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Who Was Your First...

Toss up between Joe Lally
tumblr_lt7sen6wKZ1qdru9f.jpg


or Melvin Gibbs
tubmanwilson-1.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Runlikegregg
Although I'd heard many bassists before.
I was at Fort Polk in 1969 waiting to go to Viet Nam, and saw a concert on the base by Wayne Cochran and the CC Riders, their 17 year old bassist was Jaco, he was already playing more bass than I'd ever thought anyone could play, and at 17 his genius was obvious.
Interesting. I am a huge fan of Jaco and one day I got to meet Wayne Cochran and knew that Jaco had played for him. I asked Wayne what that experience was like. He said Jaco was the best bass player and worst musician he'd ever worked with. I was shocked!! Wayne continued to say that Jaco could do amazing things but they'd be in the middle of a really sad song where the lyrics were telling an important story and Jaco would be jamming out oblivious to this.
Not every player fits in every format. I still think Jaco is one of the greatest innovators and greatest players ever. But I totally get what Wayne said and see how Jaco was not the best player for that particular band. They were eight piece when I saw them with very tight arrangements. Just not a good marriage of player and band.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LCAirPasta
Paul D'Armour believe it or not. The song "Flood" by Tool was what initially made me want to pick up bass. The whole Undertow album has great basslines. Justin Chancellor is my favorite bassist, but I think Paul does get looked over a lot when he was a pretty talented guy in his own right.
 
I first "noticed" bass in grade school. Dee Murray, specifically the Goodbye Yellow Brick Road album which is altogether brilliant, btw. The flamboyance was so fascinating at that age so Alice Cooper naturally intrigued me too although Dennis Dunaway never really came into focus for me. Naturally, I became a HUGE KISS fan and idolized Gene Simmons but as I matured more musically (I started bass at 14) I immersed myself in Led Zeppelin and to this day, JPJ is the cornerstone of my playing. I forayed down the progressive road of course: Squire, Lee, et al. and also fusion stuff. Really loved Jeff Berlin and of course Stu Hamm. Harris would probably rate as my second biggest influence. As far as Entwistle goes, I didn't pay a lot of attention to him back then but I've really developed a taste for his style which I realized that I borrow from, liberally :)
 
Last edited: