I spent a few hours with the Stomp. I can see this sticking around. I don't think it will be part of my main board, though, since I am happy with my core tone. The intention of the Stomp was to have something that I could put on a small board to cover the times when I need chorus for one song, or for when I want the Moog sound, but it's only one verse of one song--and I don't feel like bringing another instrument to cover a few bars of music. I would bring that board instead. Right now, it is sitting on a board with just the Stomp and the Tone Hammer. I may add a compressor to the front.
When I got it home, I was excited to plug it in and see what it could do. I liked some of the blocks, but I didn't hear anything that jumped out right away. I got a lot of great advise from @projectapollo and @MikoFX including about using the Edit software. Once I started editing some of the blocks, I was able to get a lot closer to something that I could see using live. I set up a block with the basics--octave, overdrive and chorus. I really like the octave patches, and I was able to get some nice chorus effects. I didn't get too deep into it yet, but I found an overdrive that I was happy with.
I'm not convinced about the amp and cab sims, yet. I've played some of the amps that they are based on and I haven't found a setting that sounds like what I remember. I'm sure I could play around with it and tweak them, but at this point, I'm not sure I want to commit the time to doing that. Maybe one day.
What really surprised me was some of the 'atmospheric' stuff. The sounds that guitar players use while the WL is speaking to the congregation, etc. I like some of those patches.
I did have a few more questions.
Is there a way to bypass the entire pedal? If I just wanted to use a block on one song, can I bypass the entire unit for the rest of the songs. The synth blocks are cool, but it would be nice to be able to put them in and out when needed.
What other pedals are you guys running on your boards? What effects can't you quite get with the Stomp?
If I edit a bunch of blocks, can it be restored to factory presets at some point?