Now that I'm at a desktop, I thought I'd elaborate on the Noble -vs- the Luce. As I mentioned, the Noble has been on my board for a bit over 2 years. Every service and every practices session. In fact, in two years I never played bass without it - except for a few brief periods of auditioning other preamps. So, that is the sound that I am used to.
When I got the Luce, I knew there was potential, but it wasn't the sound I was used to. I did a lot of a/b testing and tried a lot of different combos with the Luce. It sounds good on it's own, but I preferred it with at least some additional EQ or OD. So, I did a lot of pairings and got a bit burnt out. The plan was to put it away and revisit it when I had some time off from playing. Well, I should have known better. I just love trying new gear too much.
So, I took the best pairing--the Lightspeed OD with the tone and drive down a bit into the Luce. This gave me a tiny bit of grit and a bit of high end reduction. And I just ran through the set a few times until I started to get the Noble sound out of my head, so to speak.
Playing through the Luce is kind of making me rethink how I was using the Noble. The EQ on the Noble is incredible. On some pedals, cranking the lows is massive, but overpowering. The Noble is just so musical, and you can add a ton of low end without it being too boomy. BUT, that might have been a detrimant in this situation. I might have been pushing it too much. It would probably work better in a more sparse mix, but I think the Luce, with minimal EQ sits better for this particular mix. That is especially true with the in ears. I could hear myself so clearly. I may want to go back to the Noble and try it 'flat.' The Noble mid scoop is a lot more noticable when doing a/b testing though.
The biggest difference for me is how they feel, especially with a pick. Before I was playing worship music, I didn't use a pick at all. The Noble has this 'mushyness'-- I don't mean that as a bad thing. I quite like it at times. It's just so hard to describe tone. It's a bit slower, wheras the Luce is a bit punchier--though not as punchy as the Kahn or Caveman. This was something that I was always trying to overcome with the Noble. That's why I started using a compressor. It seemed to have better pick definition. Playing fingerstyle with the Noble is such a joy though. With the Luce, the pick attack is there.
I was surprised that I could hear quite the difference in the sanctuary during sound check (thank you Shure wireless).
In the end, there are pros and cons to each. I was scheduled to play bass in two weeks, but we had a few cancellations, so I will be playing drums then. It will be a few more weeks, but I'm going to bring the Luce back next time I'm on bass and further compare. I don't know if it was the way I was using the Noble, but I preferred the Luce on this service. It's still too early to tell.