• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Would you buy a bass without side dots?

Would you buy a bass without side dots?

  • YES

    Votes: 177 45.3%
  • NO!

    Votes: 186 47.6%
  • Carrot marks the spot!

    Votes: 28 7.2%

  • Total voters
    391
If you liked a bass enough, would you buy it if it didn't have side dots on the neck?

I have a German Hofner that doesn't have side dots. So far it's pushed me to lean more on my ears than eyes when playing.

Me, too. If it was good enough for McCartney, it's good enough for me.

You could always buy a silver Sharpie and add your own dots.
 
No dots? No problem.

images.jpg
 
I haven't had much luck with my luminlays, to be honest. Yes, they are great...when they are lit up. The only way that I have achieved that is to use the provided flash light and shine it at all the dots, one-by-one. And it's great, but only lasts about two songs.

It's possible that I'm missing something, and also haven't fully tried it live, but they don't seem to activate all that easily.
That's why I went with FretFX.
 
I had a cool vintage MIJ hollowbody guitar that didn’t have side dots. I loved the look of the thing, it sounded pretty darn good, and was comfortable enough to play…but the lack of side dots really sucked. I tried adding little pieces of electrical tape on the binding to act as side dots, but they fell off pretty quickly. Eventually I sold it after narrowly avoiding a train wreck on a gig because of the lack of side dots causing me to really mess up a song that had some fun shifts in it. It wasn’t my main guitar anyway, so out the door it went.
IMG_2271.jpeg

I won’t buy another instrument without dots.
 
For the right bass I'd accept the deficiency and pay to have them added. I don't use the fingerboard dots because none of my basses have them, but for a quick shift I'm not that good to gig without them.

Adjacent topic: Has anyone ever had standard side dots replaced with the oversized lumilay 3mm ones? Difficulty/cost? I know the neck may need a refinish and don't mind if it's just the back (no maple boards).
 
I have a German Hofner that doesn't have side dots. So far it's pushed me to lean more on my ears than eyes when playing.

All of my basses have side dots.

That said on a dim lit stage, or a stage with (hopefully :hyper:) changing stage light,

I usually don't see them at all.

They are also totally useless for headbangers and "stage runners"
metalhead.gif


But I use them to intonate (setup) my fretless, that makes them kinda important?


Would you buy a bass without side dots?

So I guess it's a "yes" for fretted (no need for side dots at all) and "no" for fretless (need them for a setup)

which makes me say: Thx for the "carrots" option! :D


greetings

Wise(b)ass