A big "no" for me. I'd rather work a regular job, save money, and go on a similar vacation with my own room. Also, it is too stressful to learn songs you may never perform again. Too many red flags. Get paid for your craft.
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Would YOU consider taking a gig like this?
- Thread starter Stingray5
- Start date
carsonchilders
Carson Childers
I would consider doing it if I had multiple additional days to a single room, could bring my wife, etc. Shared room with strangers on an island if FN weird.
But no pay and a shared room is a slap in the face for a professional... Especially when you are doing them a favor....
But no pay and a shared room is a slap in the face for a professional... Especially when you are doing them a favor....
If you were young or retired and reasonably local.... maybe.
As for schlepping equipment, I bet all you would need is your bass and a cable. Course I would recommend calling and finding out.
Shared a room with my band mates, competition partners, etc often enough to know its not the best deal, but solid earplugs help.
As for schlepping equipment, I bet all you would need is your bass and a cable. Course I would recommend calling and finding out.
Shared a room with my band mates, competition partners, etc often enough to know its not the best deal, but solid earplugs help.
Nope.
Just because something is being done for the benefit of a NFP, that doesn’t mean you don’t pay the performers. This is insulting.
Loving the different perspectives on this so far!
For the record I myself am certainly not considering this. I've actually gigged a few time out there on Fire Island, schlepping all our gear on the ferry, hauling it in wagons to the venue etc. Trying to hurry and pack up and catch the last ferry of the night... Never again! Way too much hassle.
And for this, a whole week commitment and no pay? Get outta here. I wonder how they even got the rest of the pit orchestra members to commit to something like this if they aren't getting paid? And having to share a room, it's not like you could bring your significant other and have this 'vacation' they are offering.
And they certainly are cutting it close here. Something tells me the piano player's left hand is going to be a lot busier than usual for these dates!
For the record I myself am certainly not considering this. I've actually gigged a few time out there on Fire Island, schlepping all our gear on the ferry, hauling it in wagons to the venue etc. Trying to hurry and pack up and catch the last ferry of the night... Never again! Way too much hassle.
And for this, a whole week commitment and no pay? Get outta here. I wonder how they even got the rest of the pit orchestra members to commit to something like this if they aren't getting paid? And having to share a room, it's not like you could bring your significant other and have this 'vacation' they are offering.
And they certainly are cutting it close here. Something tells me the piano player's left hand is going to be a lot busier than usual for these dates!
Your services are not compensated by anything other than admittedly wonderful accommodations, if... that's exactly what you are looking for and want. I think neither your time nor your talents are being appropriately compensated. It's not something I'd even think twice about without written guarantee of very good financial compensation, but you do you.
Sounds fun, but probably no, I wouldn't do shared housing and NO pay. I'd do cheap/friend rate. Like MAYBE as low as $400-500, with a private room. That's an absolutely screamin deal for an entire week of rehearsals and shows. I've played a number of "benefits" that still pay musicians and other staff at least somewhat. Happy to work for "benefit" rates but not really zero unless it's a ridiculously easy gig with people I actually love playing with.
A lot depends on a lot, as it were. If you are not an established player on the local scene, benefit shows done well look good on the resume. Especially on a sub basis. And the Pines is a beautiful place. Be aware that it leans significantly toward the gay male population, but they are fully accepting and respectful of other orientations.
Yes, it will be work. AND yes, it will be vacation.
Yes, it will be work. AND yes, it will be vacation.
You'd have to really WANT to be on Fire Island for a week, lugging your gear back and forth with no vehicle ... and for free. It's SOMEBODY'S idea of a good time, I'm sure. But no. No, I would not, thanks.
When my band does overnights, I absolutely refuse to share a room and we are being paid. We often get 4 rooms FOC and there are 6 of us, so four of them are sharing rooms. This sounds like a nightmare, I would play a benefit near home for free. But travel, deal with bad accommodations and not get paid, someone is getting punked and it won't be me.
Last edited:
Sounds like the guy that is in need of "last minute" replacement might have had similar thoughts...
I would dismiss consideration with extreme prejudice.
Not a chance. Real life pit gigs pay way better than this without any of the short notice and transportation issues this gig has. If you are dying to break into pit gigs, it could look good on a resume I guess. Or if you are really into the fire island vibe.
No, for all of the reasons already mentioned. Plus, on Labor Day weekend, you'll most likely be turning down one or more paying gigs to do this.
