• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Would you trade your bass competencies for something else?

I'd probably pick piano. Maybe guitar but everybody and their grandmother plays guitar.

I was thinking the other day that I wish that I had picked up the double bass and played in the high school orchestra instead of tuba in the school band.
 
Absolutely. I’d happily trade back the time I’ve spent pursuing competence in music for being a more competent husband/Father. Obviously these things aren’t mutually exclusive; however the innate self involvement that is prerequisite to being exceptional in any field can play hell on relationships.
 
I’m better on mandolin than bass. At least I get more compliments. (It may be that people like the mandolin better than bass. Or. They may like mandolin players better than bass players....) But I like being able to play different instruments (bass, guitar, mandolin, mandola, etc etc.) so I guess I would say no.
 
If you’re a really good bass player

Thanks for putting so much trust in me :D

and could start over, would you rather be a really good drummer, guitar player, piano player, etc?

No. Hadn't I wanted to play bass, why did I buy one and put all that effort into it?

In the 1970s it still was a relatively young instrument which lend itself to experimental and innovative playing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jeff Scott
I like the guy that said sketch artist and also the person that said violin. I'm really into portability these days, and the ability to be "standalone" if you want. While my competence on bass could certainly be debated, overall I've never had a problem being in a band and doing my part as a bass player. Others have said this about me and I've had many compliments, so I feel OK about my skills as a bassist in an ensemble. I'm also a decent guitarist in a band setting. Where I wish I would have focused more is singer/songwriter/acoustic. That ability to, by yourself, create something from nothing that people enjoy is not a skill I have, and one I more and more wish I had. Was just watching a Bob Dylan documentary recently and was really in awe of his ability to do this. Of course lots of other examples out there too. It's sometimes frustrating because on a technical level, I'm probably better than Bob as a guitar player. Grass is always greener I guess.
 
I’m better on mandolin than bass. At least I get more compliments. (It may be that people like the mandolin better than bass. Or. They may like mandolin players better than bass players....) But I like being able to play different instruments (bass, guitar, mandolin, mandola, etc etc.) so I guess I would say no.
So, who would you rather be: Victor Wooten, or Dave Grisman?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bushmaster