Yep. I will post. I don't need it but I waaannt it. I don't have an active BB. This one is a beaut.
Good job interesting bass that has a good value for money.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Yep. I will post. I don't need it but I waaannt it. I don't have an active BB. This one is a beaut.
The BBPH is not IMHO a 734 with a reverse P is a new instrument and with his own character.
I read his books a couple months ago, he didn't go into specifics as to what was stolen and what was replaced if I remember correctly. That is actually part of the reason why I even read them, to see if he said anything in there.Wait, the BB800 photo is from December 1980; the NY theft appears to have happened earlier that year (he was photographed at the Hurrah's gig playing a Fender Precision), so maybe the 1200 Plexi was stolen, he bought the 800, and then traded up for the 1200S before PC&L. Weird that he didn't remember having the 1200 Plexi then. Or maybe he thought that was a 600, and he bought an 800 or 1000 in NY. Except he must have had at least two 1200's, one with the pickguard and one which got loaned to Barney and modded with the bridge pup. Arrgh.
My copy of his book is in storage or I'd check to see what he wrote about it there.
he is NOT holding an eb2 in the picture where bernard is holding the bb1200. it looks like bernard's es335.Barney was using that 1200 to play Confusion (which debuted live in April of 1983), so it doesn't indicate anything about what Hooky was playing (in that same shot he can be seen with the EB-2). Note that in Pumped Full of Drugs Barney doesn't borrow Hooky's bass, he uses a 1200. It could in fact mean that Hooky had loaned him his 1200 because he had already gotten the 1200S and wasn't playing it anymore. That would mean he got the 1200S as early as spring of 1983, and used it on PC&L, which I suspect is the case.
Not a bad theory, but I think the bridge pickup was added to a 1200 they already had (hypercarrots just posted photos which support that).
I think you're right that we'll probably never know - my guess was that the bass stolen in NYC was the 1200 with the clear pickguard, which seems to have disappeared, but I'd been assuming he replaced it with a 1200S and it's pretty certain he didn't get the 1200S until he was back in Manchester. That BB800 seen in the Netherlands would make sense as the stolen guitar, although that doesn't explain what happened to Love Will Guard Us With Plexiglass. Hooky's been saying it was his Gibson copy that was stolen but I've seen a photo of that that I'm pretty sure was taken more recently than 1980.
Stainless steel frets?
I don't think so. I just happened to hear him say they were stainless in the video. I think the frets on the PH bass are different than the ones on the other BBs. I have reserved one so hopefully soon I will know.The BBP34 & 5 don't even have stainless steel do they?
he is NOT holding an eb2 in the picture where bernard is holding the bb1200. it looks like bernard's es335.
i've already said this, but in pumped full of drugs when they are playing confusion, bernard is playing a BB2000. look at the bridge pickup.
...
these aren't their usual guitars, even the black fender strat bernard uses isn't his usual. gillian plays an ibanez am205 here as well, which i haven't seen her use anywhere else.
I think you and hypercarrots have each other confused a bit here. He's talking about the picture of Barney holding the BB1200 (during Confusion), not the live performance of Thieves Like Us.
I think you and hypercarrots have each other confused a bit here. He's talking about the picture of Barney holding the BB1200 (during Confusion), not the live performance of Thieves Like Us.
He’s used other basses live but he says he has used his BB1200S on every song he’s recorded, apart from Blue Monday which featured his Shergold.Now show me a pic of Hooky when he was shaping the music of the day (Joy Division, New Order). Was he playing a bass that even remotely looked like that? He is owed better in my opinion.
Peter Hook: But, of course, I’ve got Yamahas. It’s quite funny, from a Yamaha point of view. It’s through me telling my son (Jack, bassist for Smashing Pumpkins) ...it wasn’t me meeting the Yamaha guys, it was my son. He’s much more personable than me! Bit more outgoing. He was telling the Yamaha guys that every single track that I’ve ever recorded, up to the last one I did which was the Gorillaz about a month ago, was on a Yamaha BB1200S!
Guitarguitar: Wow!
PH: So for 40 years, almost, maybe just a bit less, 37, 36 years, I’ve used the same guitar for every track.
GG: Goodness!
PH: Yeah, and I’m not too sure that there’s many a boast can be said, you know, about that!
GG: No indeed, that’s extraordinary!
PH: That started certainly with Closer, and then ended up a month ago with the Gorillaz...
PH: So, I’ve started using my new signature guitar and the Yamaha BB1200S is getting a well-deserved rest! (laughs)
GG: Fair enough, I think it’s put in a good tour of duty, hasn’t it?
PH: Mm, definitely! Bloody hell, it must’ve done...oh my god, a hundred tracks! A hundred and twenty, maybe, maybe even more than that over the years. I must do that list for Yamaha, because on a social media thing, it would look fantastic: these are aaaaall the tracks that it has played on. You know, that only one it didn’t get on, which is quite sad actually, is Blue Monday. (laughs) That was the Shergold!
That live performance that you're talking about, I think they just did Thieves Like Us that performance (Depeche Mode did People are People, it was a televised thing), so Barney wouldn't have needed the BB1200 for Confusion.Right; my point was that seeing the BB1200 on stage at the head of that video didn't mean Hooky hadn't gotten the 1200S yet, but rather that Barney had started using it for Confusion (as seen in the photo), which meant, if anything, that Hooky might have had the 1200S at that point (and left it in the studio). He wasn't using the 1200 anymore.
you're telling me things i already know and have previously statedNo, look closer, it is definitely the EB-2. The 335 has white pickup rings and a trapeze tailpiece, and has six strings; the one Hooky is holding clearly has four.
You're right that they aren't playing their usual guitars in Tokyo, but elsewhere when playing Confusion Barney uses a sunburst BB1200.