you’re not wrong - a delicate rope to tight-walk, for sure. As the guy behind the pedal, I certainly tire of f’n with it and view it as a drag on my creative magic flow, but it is undeniably a neat party trick when I can pull it off. I seriously doubt I would/could ever make a whole set of looping work. Every time I revisit the pedal, I keep hoping that it starts to happen more “effortlessly”, but tbh it always feels forced and kinda lame for exactly the reasons Damon mentioned. BUT, I’ve said it once and I’ll say it again: As a horn player, I’d rather play over a loop of myself than perform with a play-along track (cringe!). The amount of players I know who make their careers out of using Aebersold tracks with Jamie’s count-in edited out is embarrassing for the genre (IMHO, of course).Liking it and being dependent on it are two different things. A looping solo and true solo concert are also two different things. Looping solo sets are basically artificial duos and you never really get to find out what you can actually do on your own. Learning how to imply the other elements is more a valuable skill.
I think next I’m going to try more what Michael Moore’s been doing and pre-record a piano track and play bass to it — if only for an exercise.