• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

a noob question

Jun 18, 2024
491
232
Hello, Would it be a wrong technique if I pressed two strings next to each other on the same fret (for example (D string (E) and G string (A)) instead of the finger roll technique?

When i roll my finger, muting becomes much more difficult because the skin contact with the lower strings(G or D) is cut off.

Thank you
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Dillion Hanahan
If you mean Barre, then no, there's nothing wrong. If you mean with two different fingers, then again, no, nothing wrong there either, provided you don't mess up your handshape or over-extend your wrist. But I would not overlook the tip roll as another way of getting between strings
 
All of these work for me at different times...
4ths_1.jpg
4ths_2.jpg
4ths_3.jpg
4ths_4.jpg
4ths_6.jpg
 

Attachments

  • 17208059480852483938320472632028.jpg
    17208059480852483938320472632028.jpg
    2 MB · Views: 11
Sorry, I meant to say double fret with one finger.
That’s fine but if you do that with your pinkie I recommend using one of your other fingers to give your pinkie a little bit of help. Upright bass players use their pinkie in tandem with the ring finger to help with the pinkie’s lower strength.

Playing electric it isn’t as important to do that but when you barre two strings with your pinkie you’re making it do a lot more work so backing it up with the ring finger is a good idea. It helps reduce the possibility of tendonitis or other injury.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TomB
That’s fine but if you do that with your pinkie I recommend using one of your other fingers to give your pinkie a little bit of help. Upright bass players use their pinkie in tandem with the ring finger to help with the pinkie’s lower strength.

Playing electric it isn’t as important to do that but when you barre two strings with your pinkie you’re making it do a lot more work so backing it up with the ring finger is a good idea. It helps reduce the possibility of tendonitis or other injury.
Ed friedland bass method book got me used to 1-2-4 finger technique, I couldn't't support it with my ring finger
 
Sorry, I meant to say double fret with one finger.

That’s called ‘barre’, and it’s a valid technique. Some lines can’t be played without it. So it’s a good thing to know. However, it’ also important to know the other options: rolling and using two fingers. So I’d say, keep practicing those too, so you’ll have options.

When i roll my finger, muting becomes much more difficult because the skin contact with the lower strings(G or D) is cut off.

I’m not sure I understand this. When I play, for example, c-g on the G and D strings at the fifth fret using the rolling technique, my finger keeps contact with the G string when I fret D string. So the G string is muted in a very natural way.

When I use the rolling technique, I’ll often place my finger on both strings, but only push down one, so the other is muted. To change the notes, I press my finger down on the other string, but it still keeps contact with the first string I played. So it’s like a barre, except that only one string is fully pressed down at a time. This requires less force than a barre and it takes care of muting.

To try this, place your fingers as in the picture you posted. Now to play the D string, lift your finger a bit from the G string, so that the tip of your finger frets the D string and the flesh of your finger mutes the G string. Then, to play the G string, push down on the G string (that’s the rolling motion), while the tip of your finger keeps light contact with the D string, so it is muted.
 
Last edited:
That’s called ‘barre’, and it’s a valid technique. Some lines can’t be played without it. So it’s a good thing to know. However, it’ also important to know the other options: rolling and using two fingers. So I’d say, keep practicing those too, so you’ll have options.



I’m not sure I understand this. When I play, for example, c-g on the G and D strings at the fifth fret using the rolling technique, my finger keeps contact with the G string when I fret D string. So the G string is muted in a very natural way.

When I use the rolling technique, I’ll often place my finger on both strings, but only push down one, so the other is muted. To change the notes, I press my finger down on the other string, but it still keeps contact with the first string I played. So it’s like a barre, except that only one string is fully pressed down at a time. This requires less force than a barre and it takes care of muting.

To try this, place your fingers as in the picture you posted. Now to play the D string, lift your finger a bit from the G string, so that the tip of your finger frets the D string and the flesh of your finger mutes the G string. Then, to play the G string, push down on the G string (that’s the rolling motion), while the tip of your finger keeps light contact with the D string, so it is muted.
Now I understand, I guess I'm rolling my finger too much, thank you
 

Attachments

  • 17208733120911609407533265194555.jpg
    17208733120911609407533265194555.jpg
    2.4 MB · Views: 14
  • Like
Reactions: BismarckHerring

Latest posts