• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Acts that you thought would make it....

The Speedboys. From Lancaster PA. I got a chance to jam with them back in the summer of 1983. I had been in a band with one of the guitarists, Tommy Sheehan, and he brought me to one of their gigs. Their first album got a great review from the Village Voice. Christgau talking about how they were neither speedy nor boys. They put out two albums, and I guess after that they just ran out of gas. They never did tour, unless commuting to NYC from Lancaster PA counts.



Remembering Robert Bobby, the witty and warm frontman of the Speedboys
 
Last edited:
Local bands? Root Boy Slim and the Sex Change Band. Strong local following, they caught the ear of a big time producer, Gary Katz of Steely Dan fame, and the story I heard was they blew through $100,000 with nothing new to show, because giving them $100,000 just fueled their debauchery. Truly unique act, vastly under appreciated. At present, another DMV gem is Vintage 18. R&B is a tough genre. If they were younger, they’d garner more interest. Finally, out of Annapolis is Pressing Strings. They should be nationwide.
 
One of my former students has the full package to be a pop star. Great singer, creates catchy tunes, very tech/social media savvy so he puts out tons of content, has a marketable look, incredible dancer... he's doing everything he can to land opportunities, but the fish ain't biting.
 
Hothouse Flowers.


I would say Hothouse Flowers “made it” as they had a few singles that charted and lots of radio and MTV play. They just didn’t sustain that, which is a whole other thing.

I always had my fingers crossed that more people would love Velvet Crush. They were based in Rhode Island when I was in my 20s and I saw them as often as possible. They had such great songs, were on Creation right as Oasis took off and toured relentlessly. I really hoped they would get the notice they deserved.
 
Through the Eighties " Breakpoint" played NCO Clubs (like nightclubs for military servicemembers) all over Germany and England. They were a hard rock, mostly covers band, but had some great originals too. They did record and release an album in Germany. It seemed like only military people knew who they were. They were spot on playing those covers! They made the years I spent in Germany,1983-1998, more fun.
51FbMRX0wiL._SY355_.jpg
 
What, besides half the bands I was in?

In the late 80’s going into the early 90’s, in the wake of successes by Suzanne Vega, Sarah McLaughlin, and Tracy Chapman, there was a handful of female singer/songwriters who arrived with respectable debuts, and then…nothing. Maybe a second album, but then they just vanished. Perhaps they lost label support, didn’t want to play the music business game or just had some personal stuff to deal with(and not necessarily substance abuse problems). But they all had something unique going on, albeit maybe too esoteric…






Then there was someone I personally knew, that I had some small part in helping along, a guy named Frank Fairfield. Now, I do keep it in context that the appeal of what he did was limited to a special audience, but he was so good and singular that he could have gone farther; unfortunately he walked away from all of it. He was a curious combination of Doc Boggs, Fiddlin’ John Carson, and a little bit of Robert Johnson, among other things(if I’ve lost you, no problem, we’re talking about some real roots music of the early 20th century, before any specific notion of folk or country music).

I was a vendor at a music gear swap meet held in a community in the mountains above Burbank, CA. As I was setting up, I peripherally noticed a figure in a suit with a guitar sitting down to play, and when he started, my skin crawled, but in a good way. It was a rustic, ancient voice, coming from a young person, a sound of woe from times past. I turned around and here was this guy who looked like he was teleported from the Great Depression, but it was no hipster affectation, it was who he was. He lived in the neighborhood, and was just starting to go around playing on the street.

As he relied on public transportation, it was a tough go, but I helped him out a bit, had him open for a bluesy/rootsy band I was in at a club gig, and suggested that he come down to this huge record store in Hollywood where I worked, where busking near the entrance was encouraged. Through that he got noticed and signed to a small modern folk label, did one album that got rave reviews and was a hit with the Gillian Welsh/Americana crowd, and was featured(as a modern day example)in a PBS series on regional American music that became better known through the development of recording technology in the 1920’s/30’s. But for some reason(I think it might have been a negative review calling him out for being ‘inauthentic’)he soured on the whole thing and just stopped. Very disappointing, but it’s what he had to do for himself…


 
Last edited:
Another 90s band I thought would get bigger than they did was Stabbing Westward. Vocalist Christopher Hall had one hell of a voice! He could go from impassioned belting to darkly sinister softness. I think what held them back was that people thought they were a Nine Inch Nails soundalike.

The 90s was so saturated with good rock bands that many bands that would've gotten big any other era became one-hit-wonders. Belly is another one. Sure their big hit was "Feed the Tree" but that entire album Star that "Feed the Tree" on was really good.

In the late 80s/early 90s, I caught wind of a band called Love/Hate. I loved their music and lamented that they weren't bigger. Heck, their bassist Skid was their primary songwriter. "Don't Be Afraid" still has one of the most haunting (yet simple) basslines ever. And "She's An Angel" remains one of my all time favorite songs.
 
Philly hard rock band Silvertide. They’re in the Aerosmith/GnR vein, and I think their 2004 full-length album Show and Tell is fantastic. Unfortunately they haven’t released anything since then, I believe partly due to label issues. I realize their brand of old-school hard rock was in decline when they were trying to break through, but there should have been room for them. Great live shows too.

Another regional artist comes to mind, Tom Gillam. He played hard rocking country, similar to Steve Earle, and I was blown away when I saw him play The North Star Bar in Philly around 2002. Great tunes, great lyrics, and really nice dude whose lead guitarist was like a country-fried version of The Edge. His album Dallas is terrific IMO, and with the growth of Americana he should have been able to do well.
 
Game Theory is some kind of poster child for might-have-been. Strong songwriting and hooks that killed, but they were power pop, a genre which didn't get anyone famous, at least in the US. Added to that, Game Theory signed to Enigma, a label that signed a lot of interesting bands but lacked the ability to stay afloat for long. After the band broke up, Scott Miller started The Loud Family, where he doubled-down on his literary proclivities and musical experiments (the art on one of the last albums was a tribute to T.S. Eliot), securing a devoted cult following but getting a little less accessible to everyone else. For a while in the pre-Facebook/pre-Reddit era Miller ran an AMA on his website which was frequently entertaining; he was well-read, thoughtful, and treated the questions of absolute randoms with more respect than they sometimes deserved.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Michedelic
The Sky Kings. John Cowan from New Grass Revival on bass and vocals, Radney Foster vocals and guitar (wonderful songwriter too), Rusty Young (Poco) steel, Dobro, guitar. Should have been a great country pop thing before Garth Brooks' sudden success ruined commercial country music.*

*Not that Garth Brooks ruined it, but the record companies' reaction did.