• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Am I diva for not wanting to play for free?

interesting thread with lots of opposing viewpoints.

Personally, the venues I am playing at are not the same venues that a cover band playing 3 to 4 hour sets is playing. We usually play a 50 minute set sharing a bill with 2 or 3 other originals bands. most venues we are playing make you play for free starting out. You start out on wednesday opening up for free, and if you draw 30 people you MIGHT get to open up on a weekend show. If you draw 60 to 100 on a weekend then you MIGHT get offered your own show where you headline....only then do you get paid. One of my bands was getting offered these better shows....then we lost our drummer 4 months ago and are still looking for one. It's been so long we'll likely have to start all over. We are actually paying a guy to play fill in for us so we can play a show every once in a while. It's been a long and frustrating search.....DERAILMENT OVER.

Also, it is ALL about your draw....they never mention anything about the quality of your music. Moving up is strictly a game of numbers. If you can get 100 people to come to a weeknight show....you can bet you'll get offered a headlining show on a weekend real quick. Anyways, i am cool with playing for free at this point because we are moving up to better shows/venues the likely will pay. In a year if we are still slogging with these opening slots i won't be so happy about it. =).
 
Little background. I'm in my 20s, in my teens I played any gig I could get. Lets say 8 yearsish of non-stop gigging. I have pro-gear and will take the time to learn your songs.

All I ask is minimum you pay for my travel costs (couple bucks for gas and a gourmet meal at a fast food joint) So sure I'll come out for $20 rather than sit at home on my duff.

My friends give me endless hell for this. I don't have much of a day job, I'm building decent contacts and I have plenty of free time to practice on my own.

I've been emailing back and forth about filling in for a show that I can tell there's going to be no people at, 3+ practices and I'll need to lug amps. Today I find out "yeah I can't pay you anything" so I said "Sorry man, I'm not going to take a hit for your gig" I thought I was nice, now this guy is getting snooty.

Am I a jerk or am I just watching my own back? I'm interested to hear how some of you got started and your personal rules on what gigs to take and what ones to not.
Go get a 9-5,and charge at least $100.00..some people may take you a little more serious...believe it or not
 
Call him and ask him to put a check in the mail to you, maybe?

Nope... it's about the principle IMO.
:cool:

Since my last post I talked to yet another friend who this guy was calling while I was playing. Apparently he was collecting the area's first call players or something:D. He's been blowing up all of our phones trying to clean up the mess he made. I got to hear some new lies he told and it's pretty clear this guy is a master at burning bridges. I don't need the work with him.

Again, as far as I'm concerned I don't want the money or any further contact with him. If you or anyone else would like the money I'll give you his number and you can tell him you'll take it because I won't. It seems far more important to some of you than me.
;)
 
Not that I am a fan of DJ's, but one thing a DJ can offer is a wider and deeper selection of music than a band can deliver.

And you're usually limited to dealing with one potential jackass vs. multiple ones. The budget's usually lower too. Less food/drinks for the entertainment too.

Things a DJ typically doesn't offer are the dynamics nor the spontanaeity of live music.
 
interesting thread with lots of opposing viewpoints.

Personally, the venues I am playing at are not the same venues that a cover band playing 3 to 4 hour sets is playing. We usually play a 50 minute set sharing a bill with 2 or 3 other originals bands. most venues we are playing make you play for free starting out. You start out on wednesday opening up for free, and if you draw 30 people you MIGHT get to open up on a weekend show. If you draw 60 to 100 on a weekend then you MIGHT get offered your own show where you headline....only then do you get paid. One of my bands was getting offered these better shows....then we lost our drummer 4 months ago and are still looking for one. It's been so long we'll likely have to start all over. We are actually paying a guy to play fill in for us so we can play a show every once in a while. It's been a long and frustrating search.....DERAILMENT OVER.

Also, it is ALL about your draw....they never mention anything about the quality of your music. Moving up is strictly a game of numbers. If you can get 100 people to come to a weeknight show....you can bet you'll get offered a headlining show on a weekend real quick. Anyways, i am cool with playing for free at this point because we are moving up to better shows/venues the likely will pay. In a year if we are still slogging with these opening slots i won't be so happy about it. =).

That's not a derail, it's right on topic.
 
My band has a minimum. If it is not matched, we do not play.

The only exception is a charity gig. There, we ask for our regular rate and then give the charity a check from our bank account for the same amount. Both parties can claim the amount on taxes. Check with your accountant.

If a club or restaurant says our rate is "not in our budget, we pay $x" I would so like to reply, "Your $8.99 hamburgers are not in my budget, here's $1.99". But I don't. Sigh. Must try to appear to be professional.
 
And you're usually limited to dealing with one potential jackass vs. multiple ones. The budget's usually lower too. Less food/drinks for the entertainment too.

Things a DJ typically doesn't offer are the dynamics nor the spontanaeity of live music.

I agree on all points.

Confession time: I was a DJ for a while in a disco back in the mid 70's, although I hasten to add that I didn't play much "disco" music. One way the club countered the lack of spontaneity and dynamics in the recorded music was to employ a live drummer to play along with it. It worked pretty well despite the fact that I didn't work from a playlist, and there was no way for me to cue the drummer what was coming up next until it started coming out of his headphones.
 
Found this on my local Craigslist: [Invalid or Expired Link Removed]

Times are tough, and getting gigs has gotten tougher. Offers looking for musicians to play in return for exposure only abound. Don't fall for it!

Performing is a job as real as any other type of work, and your work has value. Countless hours went into developing your chops and performing takes a great deal of energy. (Can you imagine the reaction of your doctor or accountant if you told them to be content with the exposure working for you provided, and that you weren't going to pay for their services?) You have a right to earn a living working in your field, just as other professionals do.

If we musicians all stick together and refuse to work without pay, these cheap venues will have to offer at least a nominal fee if they want to continue to have live music.

Respect yourself and your talent and others will respect you. Wishing all working musicians out there the very best!
 
I agree on all points.

Confession time: I was a DJ for a while in a disco back in the mid 70's, although I hasten to add that I didn't play much "disco" music. One way the club countered the lack of spontaneity and dynamics in the recorded music was to employ a live drummer to play along with it. It worked pretty well despite the fact that I didn't work from a playlist, and there was no way for me to cue the drummer what was coming up next until it started coming out of his headphones.

That was a great way to develope a niche.
 
Found this on my local Craigslist: [Invalid or Expired Link Removed]

[...]

If we musicians all stick together and refuse to work without pay, these cheap venues will have to offer at least a nominal fee if they want to continue to have live music.

[...]
And if a frog had wings... :D

"Can you imagine the reaction of your doctor or accountant if you told them to be content with the exposure working for you provided, and that you weren't going to pay for their services?"

If there were 5 doctors for every patient, you could get really cheap (or free) medical treatment. If they banded together to drive up the price, most of them would never work again.

It ain't that simple, folks.
 
That (with the exception of benefits/volunteering).

It's hard, because a lot of your competition is willing to play for free. That sucks, but it's reality.

It sounds like you are not asking for the moon and are reasonable and flexible. Great. But maybe you need to work on your finesse and diplomacy a little. The conversation should end with them feeling GOOD about you wanting to be paid for playing, hopefully even agreeing. If you are coming off like a jerk, maybe put some time into honing your pitch. Be a class act if you want to get paid like one.

best advice so far. Make sure that he knows you only want your gas money back, $20 is not alot to ask. Also let him know that you would have appreciated knowing the no pay thing up front.