By the way, I'd be interested to hear what German forums are like!
its a tough one to word such thing out, since i could just come from one perspective, but not many at the same time. And finally a very sensible topic. But, i´d say it so:
much populated by people who want to make music by plan !
first a plan, ......you know what you do, ......then the music.
But: thats NOT what music-making has taught me.
if you are good enough, will things flow out of the context and out of the moment.
But then, some of these folks are pro, they work on the PC on their contract works.
so: different context !.......which i finally understand. But none i saw, wanted to understand their oposite. i leave it there, and don´t elaborate further, ....its better.
We had enough discussions in that direction, there.
Especially modular has taught me, that mostoften chaotic actions would even lead to better results, than anything my brain could come up with.
Instrument playing is a different topic, though.
But both realms share one thing: if you have spent so and so much hours on your instrument, is there something like "finger memory" part of the reality.
and even if you would act completly chaotic, would it remain within a certain "framework" that has been created within you.
Thats the part, none there ever could follow. ( a synthesiter community)