• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Biggest mistake a band ever made

Gotta say: Kenney Jones made total sense on paper: drummer with the other big London mod band, totally part of their social scene as a friend, had played drums on several cuts on the Quadrophenia soundtrack, no longer in the Faces who had been as big a concert draw as the Who for a few years. Listen to his drumming on this and anybody would have thought him the right man for the gig:


Yeah, that's so right. KJ was a terrific player and all those pieces you mention *should* have made him a great fit. But he just wasn't—in fact with the Who he seemed somehow more disciplined than he should have been—or than I'd seen him be beforehand. Zack Starkey was the right fit and brought some of that total manic abandon that Keith Moon brought (but thankfully not all of it). And that *was* a great fit. The Quadrophenia DVD with him on drums is a real joy.

***Not to change the subject but is that Ronnie Lane's Zemaitis bass or something else? What a bite off the top!
 
  • Like
Reactions: GregC
Born Again is highly under-rated

MI0002406573.jpg?partner=allrovi.jpg
 
Born Again is highly under-rated

MI0002406573.jpg?partner=allrovi.jpg

I completely agree! Now it helps that I'm a huge Ian Gillian fan. I think that album gets its bad rap because it sounds like a$$. I don't know who mixed or mastered it, but WTH were they thinking.

The cover doesn't help either, IMHO.

The title track, Keep it Warm, Zero the Hero, Disturbing the Priest, Trashed......some good stuff there.

Saw them on that tour as well, good show, although I suffered for a few songs midway due to a "product" I had purchased in the parking lot beforehand. Things got a bit intense for a bit. :woot:
 
The story behind Disturbing the Priest is funny, because they actually had a priest come knocking & ask them to turn it down at the castle where they were recording.

Ian has a strange/spooky story about the castle too, but I can't recall the details.
I think that's also where Ian crashed a car while loaded & the origin of Trashed came about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JMacBass65
The story behind Disturbing the Priest is funny, because they actually had a priest come knocking & ask them to turn it down at the castle where they were recording.

Ian has a strange/spooky story about the castle too, but I can't recall the details.
I think that's also where Ian crashed a car while loaded & the origin of Trashed came about.

Cool stuff, I had no idea.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Killed_by_Death
Born Again is highly under-rated

MI0002406573.jpg?partner=allrovi.jpg

I completely agree! Now it helps that I'm a huge Ian Gillian fan. I think that album gets its bad rap because it sounds like a$$. I don't know who mixed or mastered it, but WTH were they thinking.

The cover doesn't help either, IMHO.

The title track, Keep it Warm, Zero the Hero, Disturbing the Priest, Trashed......some good stuff there.

Saw them on that tour as well, good show, although I suffered for a few songs midway due to a "product" I had purchased in the parking lot beforehand. Things got a bit intense for a bit. :woot:

If you played that album to any Black Sabbath fan without telling them that it was Black Sabbath, I am sure that they will praise it to the point that they want to buy it. When you tell them that it was Black Sabbath, then the whole "I was just joking" comes out of their mouth to save face.
 
Rush:

... a more dreary, generic rock sound from 'Counterparts' onward was a huge mistake. They produced four incredible albums in a row between 'Power Windows' and 'Roll The Bones'. Rush were always about evolution but I thought the prevailing influence of alt-rock on them at the time led to a dumbing down of their sound which lasted nearly a decade. It was a long time in the wilderness for my favourite band.

See, I think Counterparts was a FANTASTIC album, that still showed classic Rush flavor on many tracks, even if it wasn't the same guitar sound or overall production sound coming out. I think it was way better than Vapor Trails and TFE, though I didn't think those were too bad either, because hey, it's still freakin Rush.
 
Hating on Mr. Roboto? And on the Jagger/Bowie cover of Dancing in the Street? Hate leads to the dark side y'know... =)
I was never a big fan of Styx--but Mr Roboto has to be the worst thing they ever released.
I've seen it on several worst songs by a band you like/songs that killed a band/etc type lists

You are allowed to disagree--I certainly disagree with things in this thread--and have mentioned some.
 
I was never a big fan of Styx--but Mr Roboto has to be the worst thing they ever released.
I've seen it on several worst songs by a band you like/songs that killed a band/etc type lists

You are allowed to disagree--I certainly disagree with things in this thread--and have mentioned some.
I don't recall ever having heard it before, but then again I was never into Styx.
 
Hating on Mr. Roboto? And on the Jagger/Bowie cover of Dancing in the Street? Hate leads to the dark side y'know... =)
My first tattoo was the lips&tongue Rolling Stones logo. It was bad enough when the late 80's came around & they released Dirty Work, but when this horrific duet happened (and i honestly love both Mick & David!), i went to a tattoo shop and had them do a real nice cover up!

The only Rush album I didn't like was the one where they did covers from their youth.
Was that the 4 or 5 song EP they released sometime after 2000?
 
  • Like
Reactions: JMacBass65
I was never a big fan of Styx--but Mr Roboto has to be the worst thing they ever released.

Ha, I'm not a fan of Styx either, but yeah Mr. Roboto... I don't just sing along, I jump out of my chair and act it out.

My first tattoo was the lips&tongue Rolling Stones logo. It was bad enough when the late 80's came around & they released Dirty Work, but when this horrific duet happened (and i honestly love both Mick & David!), i went to a tattoo shop and had them do a real nice cover up!

Yeah being a Stones fan can take you through some ups and downs... Dirty Work was as awful as the cover of the album. I'm a fan of the duet though, and it's a throwback to early rock too... but hey each his own. Though covering up a tattoo for it? What'd you get btw? Tell me a hot fat girl sticking out her tongue, with a hit of acid on it...

Have you checked out the new album, all blues covers? It's damn good...
 
  • Like
Reactions: catcauphonic

Latest posts