No offense but are you serious about a tonal diff from the guard????
Yeah sorry Jonno, I am in effect VERY SERIOUS.
Ask Jimmy his take ?
Why wouldn`t a singly layer of plastic not vibrate, or allow more wood vibrations of a bass body than 3 laminates ?
Fender used single ply bakelite on the first mid 50`s Strat guitars, and ash body and age not withstanding, those guitars are ultra serious tone monsters.
I AM NOT SAYING EVERY STRAT with a single ply guard is going to sound better than a STRAT with a tortoise/laminate guard BUT the same guitar will sound different with the 2 different guards, I am certain.
Does a laminate bodied upright resonate as much as a wooden bass generally-especially with a bow ??? Perhaps not always discernable by playing solely pizz but there is a difference in a lam body versus a carved ( wooden) body when played arco (bow).
Also ( player not withstanding ) JACO gets a heck of a tone out of that fretless without a pickguard.
MANY high end makers of basses eschew pickguards. Ken Smith, MTD, TOBIAS, SPECTOR, MODULUS, WARWICK, FODERA, PEDULLA and ALEMBIC to name a few.
Of course a few of the above makers may have models w/guards but they are usually FENDER copies, aren`t they ?
IF SAY, YOU HAVE NOT TRIED IT, WELL THEN I INVITE YOU TO, AND THEN SEE FOR YOURSELF IF I AM SERIOUS OR NOT ???

