Need help on scale length.
I am working out the details on a 5 or 6 string and would really appreciate some feedback on scale length from everyone.
I may be of service here.
Prior to 2003, I played standard 34" scale four stringed basses. When I decided to go to 5 or 6 strings, I began that quest for a good sounding and good playability on a B string. I found a lot of 34" scale basses that had floppy B strings and/or muddy sounding B strings. When I say floppy, I mean the playability of the string, meaning the tension on the string was too low for my liking. When I say muddy, I mean that the B string sounded muffled or poorly defined. Having Bass Central two hours away, and a number of other standard music stores near me, I had the opportunity to try a lot of production basses and a lot of boutique basses.
I first purchased a 35" scaled 6 string for a couple of years, then settled down to 35" scaled 5 stringed basses. I'm a five player. So for about nine years, I thought you had to have a 35" scale to have a good B string.
Having been a fan of Cliff's work for about eight or nine years, I first ordered a 35" scaled 5 string in October 2011. I'm glad the wait was 14 months on that build. I was interested in getting a shorter scaled bass, but was concerned about the B string on such an instrument. I also read about how wonderful Cliff's 32" scaled 5 and 6 stringed basses were here at Talkbass, but I had to try it myself before I would believe it. Before he started work on my bass, Cliff had two 32" scaled basses finished in April 2012-- I think one was a 5 and the other a 6. Cliff was nice enough to allow me to come to his shop and play these two basses before he shipped them out to their owners. Other than the speeding ticket I got on the Florida Turnpike, it was a wonderful experience. I found the B string articulate and quite playable. The tension was not as tight as my 35" scaled basses, but it was much better and much more playable than almost all 34" scaled basses I had tried. That night, I changed my order from a 35" to a 32" scale 5 string before I left to drive back home.
I got my first CB 32" scaled 5 string in December 2012 and my second (fretless) in April 2013. I've been playing those two basses exclusively since I got them, and I love them.
Disclaimer: I play mostly pop, rock, disco, Motown, R&B and a little country. I don't sit on the B string all night. I may not use the B string on every song, but when I need it, it is a good sounding, good playing B string. I don't know how Cliff does it, but it works. I wanted to order a third 32" 5, but I couldn't swing the payment-- perhaps next year.
I'm sure others can chime in about Cliff's medium, standard and extra long scale B string. I didn't mention the C string at all.
Sorry this was so long.