I'm not adverse to it at all, in fact my step son (15 years old) asks why all my basses are wood. Why not red or black or purple!!??
There obviously are a LOT of people out there that love the gloss solid finishes.
And you are right, the phoenix copes well with the extras!
Just had a thought, my Wood voice gives me all this greif on solid finishes.....
BUt He also wants me to get a chambered felicia 6 string fretless from Tom - with lots of HOLES in it!!! I mean I was positively drooling over nofretz new baby.
So whats worse, cutting holes in your baby -or wrapping it in plastic??
It's all about the sum total of the design. The components as they read as a whole, not just as individual parts. The wood + hardware + body shape + the colors of everything + texture and figuring of wood...
How many times have we gone " Wowzers look at that ridiculously awesome Buckeye Burl!" bet couldn't determine where the pickups or the control knobs were. Or that the hardware looked out of place or stapled on to the instrument...
Form follows function. In other words it needs to have a purpose to some degree to validate sexiness...

