Thanks. Another question (for anyone) re my thoughts for a PJ. Has anyone tried an alder/maple combo? I know Roger recommends ash with maple and that's the only config I've ever seen on the website. I'm leaning toward maple, but I'm much more an alder fan.
/rick
The 2005 black/maple NYC P5 in my avatar is alder/maple. I think it's still my favorite bass (possibly tied with an alder/maple bass of another brand). I also own an NYC P5 in alder/Brazilian -- lovely sounding bass (which I usually keep strung with flats/tapes), but I prefer alder/maple.
Also, for a few months I owned an ash/maple NYC PJ5. Nice bass, but it didn't tickle my ears as much as alder/maple so I sold it. Same was true for an ash/maple Fender 57 RI, and ash/rosewood Lull P5 I had owned previously. Given that I've had consistent good luck with alder and not-so-good luck with ash, I've been sticking with alder. By that same token, if your ears have been consistently pleased by alder/maple, it probably makes sense for you to stick with it as well.