So, did some side-by-side, on-the-gig testing with my Sadowsky(s):
LONG story short is that I'll be putting this one up for sale. Glad I got to try this wood combo out, but it breaks down like this:
1) My flat-wound and foam mute-equipped PJ5 (alder/braz rw) is simply the best bass I own for old school tones
2) My fretless Modern/M24-5 has 'that' sound in spades, and switching back and forth between it and the fretted Satin above was illuminating. The NYC fretless (aside from the really obvious frets-versus-no-frets thing) just had more balance across the fretboard. The fretted Satin, and to me all of the Modern Pickup Sadowskies reveal the following to me:
PROS
- Absolutely perfect B-string clarity
- THE best 'back by the bridge' tone ever
CONS (for me):
- Notes in the middle of the neck on the D/G string are a little thin (yes I use the setup guide and a machinist ruler)
- Slap tone really sits in a mix perfectly, without overwhelming it, but is in the end an acquired taste.
3) My 'I can't believe the sacrilege' MTD 634, which has a Sadowsky Pre and Aguilar Big Single pickups. You wouldn't believe all the warm, tube-like warmth that Roger's pre imparts to this bass, which is very 'Warwicky' for lack of a better term. All walnut body, no top, and with a Wenge neck and board. VTC off? The 6-string Sadowsky I've always dreamed of. VTC on? More complex and mid-rich take on the J-bass tone when slapped, and a down right nasty/who-put-a-hamhock-in-my-cornflakes neck pickup tone when slapped.
More crow eating here.
I posted elsewhere about the wisdom of following Saint Roger's setup guide to the MM, and even had a lively exchange and was hereby humbled by said master (I rose stronger, and it twas only a flesh wound), and yet ...
I was rolling out with a bass that wasn't quite to those vaunted standards.
All of the things I listed about this Satin were still bugging me, which was unfortunate because it was so close to being the
perfect modern R&B/Neo-Soul bass for my main gig.
Welp, I done figured it out.
First step was to ditch the green coated DR strings, that while looking bad to the bone live, were missing something in the low-mids. I slapped soem D'Addario Steels on there, and right off the bat the improvement was immense.
Whilst tweaking the thing (god I love when I get to use the word 'whilst') I noticed that I hadn't even bothered to check my pickup height. I was so used to my other Sadowski, where bridge/pickup/string type has remained such a constant that only a truss rod tweak was needed every so often, that I was remiss in my duties.
Played a gig a few weeks back, and with my 3-bass Hercules Stand in place, I had my Fretless Modern, the Satin, and my Chromes-strung, Big Daddy P, lean/mean Seafoam Green Wrecking Machine.
Could not conceive of a better setup.
Well ...
Maybe an ash/maple PJ5 ... or a Musicman-Dowsky, but thereby hangs another tale.