• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Compressor that just compresses?

I'm new to compressors -- recently bought a TC Spectracomp and have been playing around with it at home, haven't had occasion to gig with it yet. I notice it adds a bassiness to the tone. When I have it on, and turn up the lone dial on this puppy, it increases the volume and basses up the tone. I have to crank up the treble on my amp to counteract this.

I am wondering if there is a compressor that just compresses, without boosting volume or changing the tone. I have read maybe a third of scubaduba's epic compressor comparison threads so far. If I'm understanding scuba's reviews correctly, it sounds like the MXR M87 comes pretty close to what I'm asking about. Compression without coloring the tone. Not sure about how much it boosts volume.

Scuba or anybody else, do I have that right? Are there other compressors that just compress?
The spectra comp actually compresses each string differently. But in general, compressors add low end, lower output, and keep everything on an even keel. As in, remove dynamics from your playing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nomogram
I had the MXR M87 as my first compressor. It was good for a bit but then I started to find that it isn't as transparent as I'd have liked. It might just be with certain basses, but I found with my active basses that it was definitely losing something when I kicked on the compressor. Even with very little compression going on I could hear the change in tone when I kicked it on. I've since switched to the Empress Compressor and I find it to be much more transparent. Just my experience though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MynameisMe
These pedal compressors for the most part, they really cannot touch studio grade compressors for transparency. I would look for a used DBX and they would be cheaper than most pedals. However I like that some of them for the sound that they add, like the Pigtronix and the Boss pedals. Pyscho-acoustic wise, any compressor would change perceived tone because volume affects tone to the human ear. If you have some money to spend for a bass/guitar instrument specific compressor, Summit Audio's TLA-50 iI think is awesome and is usually paired with the TD-100. I do not have personally but have tried my buddy's setup. It does sweeten the sound a bit, to me anyways

Since I have an Apollo Twin Interface -- I just connect my bass to it and use a virtual compressor Manley Variable that came with my unit when I got it used. It has very low latency and I have used it live with zero issues. So if have a UAD device even the default compressor plugins are top notch.

I still think those old DBX 163x's that you can find on CL - do a wonderful job and they are cheap. Found one locally for 75
 
Last edited:
The EBS compressor does it. it's so transparent you might wonder if it's working - but play hard, record it and look at your output, it's doing it's thing. And it can have a bit of an audible tone if you want it to, but it's certainly one of the most transparent magical bass compressors in existence.... not to mention simple to dump into your chain without issues - you could buy it, throw it in your chain at a gig at start of chain, and not even worry about it..... (although that would be dumb to do LoL without learning how to use it best...)

Yes, the EBS Multicomp in "normal" mode is nicely unintrusive. The other modes (tubesim/multi) are also well-done so it might save you money in the future as well. (It's also pretty much the only comp pedal I can stand on bass really.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: dkelley
or one that kinda does both things ... color or Not ...

recently picked up a used Taurus Tux Opti MK-2 ... so far = very interesting

other variable type sounding comps i have tried - Seymour Duncan Studio Bass - interesting filters

Keeley Bassist has always been said to be transparent here in TB ... sounds interesting , on the ' need to try ' list ...
 
A one knob compressor may not be that useful for your expectations. Compressors can do so much more than that, and have a lot of uses and capability.

That is why many well built ones include input Gain, Threshold, Attack, Release, and Ratio controls, along with a volume control.

Personally I love my Markbass Compressore. Well worth it if you can locate one. They were built for years, but recently discontinued. But has had absolutely great reviews over the years. Great quality.

BTW - the 2nd generation had recessed controls so it won't change settings if bumped. Something to look for if you find one.
ljbcm6xvkce4qgkpvx9z.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: One Way
I have always liked the idea of compressors and had a couple over the years, but didn't like that they squished my sound. I just wanted something that added a little something without affecting my tone. I am now using an Empress Compressor and for me, it does just that. That being said, I haven't tried many others, including the MXR that many are recommending.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MynameisMe
Fantastic, inexpensive, quiet, versatile, and very easy-to-use pedal compressor is the Seymour Duncan Studio Bass. Good luck finding anything that meets or beats it in many, much less all, of those metrics. And it also has some very easy-to-use EQ options at the flick of a toggle if you want that someday.


The spectra comp actually compresses each string differently.

Some of the "toneprints" may be multi-band. I'm unsure. But no compressor can possibly compress each string differently as it can't possibly have any idea which string is being played, or even what type of instrument. That may be a bit semantical and I'd have not responded except...

But in general, compressors add low end,

No. Some have a baked-in EQ that may sound like there's more low end, but compressing doesn't add low end. Many compressors lose low end, or squash it too much vs. lower-amplitude high end and that's why some prefer multi-band or the ability to blend the dry uncompressed tone which is a typical feature of "bass compressors", and many more muddy the highs which can sound like more low end but isn't the case.


lower output,

Yes, but that's why all of them have make-up gain so you can put the output at unity gain or make the output far louder than the input signal. It's quite difficult, perhaps impossible, to find a compressor - especially a pedal compressor - without user-controlled make-up gain.


and keep everything on an even keel. As in, remove dynamics from your playing.

Again, not so. The higher amplitudes are tamed, or more accurately compressed closer to the lower-amplitude dynamics. However while your louder playing is compressed, your softer playing is at the same time made effectively easier to hear (or apparently louder). So some dynamics are lowered while others are comparatively boosted. This point may not matter to someone who has no subtlety in their playing, but the boosting of signal or technique and string noise via compression should still be considered.
 
I'm new to compressors -- recently bought a TC Spectracomp and have been playing around with it at home, haven't had occasion to gig with it yet. I notice it adds a bassiness to the tone. When I have it on, and turn up the lone dial on this puppy, it increases the volume and basses up the tone. I have to crank up the treble on my amp to counteract this.

I am wondering if there is a compressor that just compresses, without boosting volume or changing the tone. I have read maybe a third of scubaduba's epic compressor comparison threads so far. If I'm understanding scuba's reviews correctly, it sounds like the MXR M87 comes pretty close to what I'm asking about. Compression without coloring the tone. Not sure about how much it boosts volume.

Scuba or anybody else, do I have that right? Are there other compressors that just compress?


Did you ever try to turn down the bass, rather than turn up the treble?
 
I've got the MXR bass compressor you speak of, and I love it:

mxr-m87-bass-compressor_1_1028x.jpg


Every time I buy an MXR pedal I'm surprised at the level of quality for the cost, and this would be no exception. They make great stuff for bassists.

The "input" and "output" knobs give you a lot of control over the final volume.
 
Did you ever try to turn down the bass, rather than turn up the treble?

Yes, I did, and it didn't have much effect unless I turned up the treble too.

Since I posted my original post that started this thread, I have downloaded a couple of the other "tone prints" from TC Electronics, and found one that I like better, that isn't as boomy. I think it's called "Straight Up The Middle" or maybe "Right Down The Middle" or something like that, because presumably it has more even distribution across the frequency range. It doesn't add the bassiness that the factory setting did. I'll keep playing with the TC, before I buy a different compressor. But it's good to know that several other models have such good reviews from TBers.
 

Latest posts