• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Covers you refuse to play now or ever again

"I don't understand why no one is coming to our gigs. We pick really interesting covers that we like to play and no one else does. I just don't get it."

Set list choice will make or break a band. Most of the audience wants familiarity. If you're killing it on the songs you're playing and no one is showing, consider changing your list.

Refusing to play a song because you don't like it is silly. I'm playing songs I never would've considered. Our singer has a knack for picking a set list that has everybody dancing from the first downbeat to the final note of the night. I don't even question anymore.

You say play, I say how loud?
 
Never say never. For a few years after it came out, everyone played Smoke on the Water. For a couple decades, nobody played it - it'd been overdone. I was in a band that played it a couple decades after it'd stopped being played, and everyone in the band and the audience loved it - it was buried deep in everyone's sub conscious, and had become cool again.
 
If you're in a cover band there is virtually NO song you should say you WON'T EVER PLAY. People want familiar, and your job is to entertain, keeping people at the establishment to eat, drink, and be merry.

Brown Eyed Girl, Mustang Sally, Sweet Caroline......those are never on our setlist but you be damned certain we can wing them out anytime someone wants to hear it.

Maybe it's just me, but I still have fun playing songs that I would never listen to if the crowd likes them!
 
Never say never. For a few years after it came out, everyone played Smoke on the Water. For a couple decades, nobody played it - it'd been overdone. I was in a band that played it a couple decades after it'd stopped being played, and everyone in the band and the audience loved it - it was buried deep in everyone's sub conscious, and had become cool again.

There are songs that make a comeback as well as obscure tunes waiting for someone to haul them back. I worked up a somewhat rocked out arrangement of Love Potion Number Nine. It went over like crazy at every venue we played it at. I used to laugh a bit because I knew that most it not all of the younger people probably had never heard it.